This study provides valuable insight into the timing of meltwater events and associated response of AMOC during the last deglaciation. The strength of the work lies in its precisely dated chronology from a northwest Iberian stalagmite, which overcomes the chronological limitations of North Atlantic sediment records. As highlighted by Reviewer 2 “this represents a substantial advance given the impasse in what is possible based on the less precise dates of sediment cores in this interval.” The analysis of multiple proxies within the same stalagmite allows the authors to directly compare the timing of surface ocean freshening relative to regional temperature changes. Their findings reinforce the hypothesis that the AMOC response to freshwater forcing is nonlinear and may involve threshold-like transitions that are dependent on background climate states. This has broader relevance to the ongoing debate surrounding future AMOC stability.

The expansion of the glacial ice shield on Iceland and its lateral expansion is a big unknown in paleoclimate and paleoceanography. Its expansion into the Denmark Strait region has major implication on the water mass exchange across the Strait, in particular for the outlfow of Denmark Strait Overflow Water. This modeling study is bringing exciting new insights and constrains on the behavior of the Iceland ice cap throughout the last glacial cycle.