Articles | Volume 22, issue 11
https://doi.org/10.5194/cp-22-2153-2026
© Author(s) 2026. This work is distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
How abruptly did the Holocene Green Sahara end?
Download
- Final revised paper (published on 20 Nov 2026)
- Preprint (discussion started on 20 May 2026)
Interactive discussion
Status: closed
Comment types: AC – author | RC – referee | CC – community | EC – editor | CEC – chief editor
| : Report abuse
-
RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-2587', Anonymous Referee #1, 19 Jun 2026
- AC1: 'Reply on RC1', Martin Claussen, 15 Jul 2026
-
RC2: 'Valuable and comprehensive manuscript; could use a little streamlining', Jed Kaplan, 29 Jun 2026
- AC2: 'Reply on RC2', Martin Claussen, 15 Jul 2026
Peer review completion
AR – Author's response | RR – Referee report | ED – Editor decision | EF – Editorial file upload
ED: Submit a revised manuscript (21 Jul 2026) by Gerrit Lohmann
AR by Martin Claussen on behalf of the Authors (21 Sep 2026)
Author's response
Author's tracked changes
Manuscript
ED: Referee Nomination & Report Request started (06 Oct 2026) by Gerrit Lohmann
RR by Anonymous Referee #1 (13 Oct 2026)
RR by Jed Kaplan (25 Oct 2026)
ED: Publish subject to minor revisions (review by editor) (04 Nov 2026) by Gerrit Lohmann
AR by Martin Claussen on behalf of the Authors (11 Nov 2026)
Author's response
Author's tracked changes
Manuscript
ED: Publish as is (11 Nov 2026) by Gerrit Lohmann
AR by Martin Claussen on behalf of the Authors (12 Nov 2026)
Manuscript
Review of “How abruptly did the Holocene Green Sahara end?” by Claussen et al.
This manuscript provides a highly rigorous quantitative framework to evaluate the termination of the African Holocene Humid Period (AHHP). The authors successfully move the long-standing debate from a qualitative discussion of "collapse vs. gradual decline" to a standardized, metric-driven assessment. The integration of transient simulations from the MPI-ESM with carefully aggregated pollen groups and marine dust flux records is solid. By applying a changepoint detection method to linear regressions, the authors effectively demonstrate that the end of the Green Sahara was characterized by a complex spatial and temporal mosaic: a gradual expansion of desert areas on a macro scale, accompanied by abrupt, step-like transitions within specific PFTs and regional ecosystems. The discussion of the limitations of the single model study (such as the challenge of representing savanna biomes in JSBACH), and the uneven distribution of proxy data availability provides a clear path forward. The manuscript is a pleasure to read, and my comments below are offered as minor (and mostly technical) suggestions to further polish an already outstanding paper.
1. As the authors noted, the complete omission of the Sahelian group from the model comparison—due to JSBACH's known inability to accurately simulate savanna ecosystems—is a significant limitation. Given that the Sahelian transition is central to the aridification of the Sahara, the authors should explicitly outline how the lack of a savanna biome representation might skew the modeled rapidity of the bare-surface expansion. If grass and trees cannot properly co-exist as savanna in the model, does the transition to bare soil appear artificially abrupt?
2. Orbital forcing vs. internal variability. The definition of abruptness relies on changes occurring faster than the linear trend in orbital forcing. While this is a solid baseline, it would be beneficial to elaborate on the potential role of unforced, centennial-scale internal climate variability. Does the MPI-ESM transient simulation show periods where internal variability can coincidentally push the vegetation over a bioclimatic threshold or beyond the defined abruptness threshold, accelerating the transition independently of the orbital decline?
3. To restrict the changepoint detection a priori to a single transition in linear regression is a logical choice to isolate the primary step-like termination of the AHHP. However, some of the highly variable proxy records (and perhaps some regional grid boxes in the transient simulation) might naturally exhibit multi-stage transitions or "flickering" before settling into a desert state. The authors might consider adding brief discussion on whether releasing this single-changepoint constraint in future studies might reveal secondary and smaller transitional phases.
4. To ensure consistency between the high-resolution simulation output and the proxy data, the authors interpolate pollen and dust records to annual values before applying a 500-year Butterworth filter. Because the temporal resolution of the proxy records varies considerably (e.g., from roughly 50 years to nearly 400 years for pollen, and up to 990 years for the GC49 marine core), the authors might briefly clarify if the interpolation process introduces any minor spectral artifacts or aliasing, particularly for the coarsest records. A minor note assuring the reader that the changepoint detection is insensitive to this specific interpolation step would be a helpful technical addition.
Typos:
L46. adaption -> adaptation
L101. On the northern hemisphere... -> In the …
L133. contritbutors -> contributors
L146. 8000 year -> years
L152. …even more as… -> even more so as
L195. "mineral dust update". Do you mean “uptake”?