Dear authors,

Thank you for submitting your responses to the three reviewer’s comments. Based on their comments, major revisions are necessary.

Hence, I invite you to submit a revised version of your manuscript, incorporating all changes following the reviewer’s comments. With your revised document, also please provide a detailed response to the reviewer comments i.e. provide more specific details than you have done so far on the changes you made.

Please submit also both a version with track changes and a clean version.
I will send the revised version of your manuscript and the detailed answers to their comments back to the reviewers for evaluation.

Many thanks in advance.

Best regards,

Emilie Capron
Guest Editor, Climate of the Past

Dear authors,

Thank you for your answers to the reviews and your revised manuscript.
You will find additional comments from two of the reviewers. Please consider all of them when preparing a final version of your manuscript.

All the best.
Emilie Capron

Dear authors,

Thanks for your revised version, I'm happy to accept your manuscript for publication.

Best.
Emilie Capron (guest editor, CP)