Dear Author,
As you can see in the discussion Forum, I have now received the assessment of two reviewers for your MS. Alongside with the reviews, you received some very interesting (and helpful) comments from two colleagues who commented in the forum.

I appreciate that you took the time to answer all of them, indicating how you will address their points in the next version of the MS. This makes the job of an editor very easy.

Both reviewers and the colleagues posting comments point out that this is a good piece of work, albeit they raise potential issues, some parts where your work could be more clear and, as in the case of Figure 2 and Figure 4, points that need to be fixed in your final MS.

I would encourage you to work on your MS keeping in mind the suggestions that you received in CP Discussions, which I consider overall as moderate.

Thank you for choosing CP for your work, I am looking Forward to see the final version of the MS complete with answers to reviewers and, where applicable, to the other scientists who commented on your paper.

My best regards,
Alessio Rovere

Dear Author,
I am happy to inform you that your MS is acceptable for publication.
Many thanks for choosing Climate of the Past for publishing your research.
Alessio Rovere