|
21 Oct 2008
Status : this preprint has been withdrawn by the authors.
Were last glacial climate events simultaneous between Greenland and western Europe?
M. Blaauw , B. Wohlfarth , J. A. Christen , L. Ampel , D. Veres , K. A. Hughen , F. Preusser , and A. Svensson
During the last glacial period, several large abrupt climate fluctuations took place on the Greenland ice cap and elsewhere. Often these Dansgaard/Oeschger events are assumed to have been synchronous, and then used as tie-points to link chronologies between the proxy archives. However, if temporally separate events are lumped into one illusionary event, climatic interpretations of the tuned events will obviously be flawed. Here, we compare Dansgaard/Oeschger-type events in a well-dated record from south-eastern France with those in Greenland ice cores. Instead of assuming simultaneous climate events between both archives, we keep their age models independent. Even these well-dated archives possess large chronological uncertainties, that prevent us from inferring synchronous climate events at decadal to multi-centennial time scales. If possible, tuning of proxy archives should be avoided.
This preprint has been withdrawn.
Received: 27 Aug 2008 – Discussion started: 21 Oct 2008
Publisher's note : Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this preprint. The responsibility to include appropriate place names lies with the authors.
M. Blaauw , B. Wohlfarth , J. A. Christen , L. Ampel , D. Veres , K. A. Hughen , F. Preusser , and A. Svensson
Interactive discussion
Status: closed
Status: closed
AC : Author comment | RC : Referee comment | SC : Short comment | EC : Editor comment
- Printer-friendly version
- Supplement
Interactive discussion
Status: closed
Status: closed
AC : Author comment | RC : Referee comment | SC : Short comment | EC : Editor comment
- Printer-friendly version
- Supplement
M. Blaauw , B. Wohlfarth , J. A. Christen , L. Ampel , D. Veres , K. A. Hughen , F. Preusser , and A. Svensson
M. Blaauw , B. Wohlfarth , J. A. Christen , L. Ampel , D. Veres , K. A. Hughen , F. Preusser , and A. Svensson
Viewed
Total article views: 1,500 (including HTML, PDF, and XML)
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
BibTeX
EndNote
1,005
392
103
1,500
76
96
HTML: 1,005
PDF: 392
XML: 103
Total: 1,500
BibTeX: 76
EndNote: 96
Views and downloads (calculated since 01 Feb 2013)
Month
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
Feb 2013
1
4
2
7
Mar 2013
2
7
2
11
Apr 2013
1
4
0
5
May 2013
1
6
0
7
Jun 2013
3
7
0
10
Jul 2013
8
0
8
Aug 2013
3
5
0
8
Sep 2013
5
6
0
11
Oct 2013
1
4
0
5
Nov 2013
2
5
0
7
Dec 2013
1
7
0
8
Jan 2014
5
4
0
9
Feb 2014
5
10
2
17
Mar 2014
7
5
0
12
Apr 2014
3
5
0
8
May 2014
3
8
0
11
Jun 2014
1
5
0
6
Jul 2014
5
9
0
14
Aug 2014
4
11
0
15
Sep 2014
2
14
0
16
Oct 2014
4
5
0
9
Nov 2014
4
6
1
11
Dec 2014
9
0
9
Jan 2015
5
0
5
Feb 2015
6
3
0
9
Mar 2015
12
3
0
15
Apr 2015
9
1
0
10
May 2015
3
0
3
Jun 2015
5
0
5
Jul 2015
7
2
0
9
Aug 2015
8
6
0
14
Sep 2015
2
0
2
Oct 2015
4
2
0
6
Nov 2015
9
4
1
14
Dec 2015
3
0
3
Jan 2016
10
5
1
16
Feb 2016
6
5
0
11
Mar 2016
7
2
0
9
Apr 2016
6
2
0
8
May 2016
6
3
0
9
Jun 2016
3
0
3
Jul 2016
4
1
5
Aug 2016
2
2
0
4
Sep 2016
2
2
0
4
Oct 2016
3
1
0
4
Nov 2016
2
0
2
Dec 2016
4
3
0
7
Jan 2017
6
1
0
7
Feb 2017
5
0
5
Mar 2017
13
3
1
17
Apr 2017
31
3
7
41
May 2017
33
8
41
Jun 2017
31
7
38
Jul 2017
9
2
1
12
Aug 2017
6
5
0
11
Sep 2017
9
6
0
15
Oct 2017
8
1
0
9
Nov 2017
13
1
0
14
Dec 2017
19
2
0
21
Jan 2018
17
3
0
20
Feb 2018
21
3
24
Mar 2018
14
3
0
17
Apr 2018
11
3
0
14
May 2018
10
4
2
16
Jun 2018
9
1
0
10
Jul 2018
15
3
1
19
Aug 2018
11
1
0
12
Sep 2018
10
1
0
11
Oct 2018
6
4
0
10
Nov 2018
9
3
1
13
Dec 2018
7
1
0
8
Jan 2019
10
6
0
16
Feb 2019
8
1
0
9
Mar 2019
7
3
0
10
Apr 2019
8
2
1
11
May 2019
8
1
0
9
Jun 2019
4
4
0
8
Jul 2019
5
4
0
9
Aug 2019
7
5
0
12
Sep 2019
4
0
4
Oct 2019
3
1
0
4
Nov 2019
6
2
0
8
Dec 2019
3
1
0
4
Jan 2020
7
1
0
8
Feb 2020
5
3
1
9
Mar 2020
2
0
2
Apr 2020
6
0
6
May 2020
7
1
8
Jun 2020
8
0
8
Jul 2020
10
8
8
26
Aug 2020
2
1
2
5
Sep 2020
3
2
0
5
Oct 2020
2
0
2
Nov 2020
5
4
1
10
Dec 2020
6
3
1
10
Jan 2021
5
3
0
8
Feb 2021
5
1
0
6
Mar 2021
8
3
0
11
Apr 2021
2
1
0
3
May 2021
7
2
0
9
Jun 2021
8
2
0
10
Jul 2021
6
1
0
7
Aug 2021
8
0
8
Sep 2021
8
2
0
10
Oct 2021
14
1
0
15
Nov 2021
11
2
0
13
Dec 2021
7
4
1
12
Jan 2022
9
1
0
10
Feb 2022
8
1
2
11
Mar 2022
9
1
3
13
Apr 2022
10
1
1
12
May 2022
4
1
5
Jun 2022
2
1
1
4
Jul 2022
2
0
2
Aug 2022
9
2
1
12
Sep 2022
1
1
2
4
Oct 2022
6
2
2
10
Nov 2022
8
3
2
13
Dec 2022
13
5
5
23
Jan 2023
6
1
1
8
Feb 2023
10
2
2
14
Mar 2023
12
0
12
Apr 2023
6
1
2
9
May 2023
5
4
0
9
Jun 2023
6
2
0
8
Jul 2023
16
1
0
17
Aug 2023
5
1
0
6
Sep 2023
8
3
1
12
Oct 2023
13
1
1
15
Nov 2023
1
0
1
Dec 2023
6
0
6
Jan 2024
6
0
6
Feb 2024
7
3
0
10
Mar 2024
10
3
0
13
Apr 2024
6
4
4
14
May 2024
14
4
5
23
Jun 2024
4
1
5
Jul 2024
12
3
2
17
Aug 2024
6
2
2
10
Sep 2024
13
1
1
15
Oct 2024
10
3
1
14
Nov 2024
13
3
16
Cumulative views and downloads
(calculated since 01 Feb 2013)
Month
HTML views
PDF downloads
XML downloads
Feb 2013
1
4
2
Mar 2013
3
11
4
Apr 2013
4
15
4
May 2013
5
21
4
Jun 2013
8
28
4
Jul 2013
8
36
4
Aug 2013
11
41
4
Sep 2013
16
47
4
Oct 2013
17
51
4
Nov 2013
19
56
4
Dec 2013
20
63
4
Jan 2014
25
67
4
Feb 2014
30
77
6
Mar 2014
37
82
6
Apr 2014
40
87
6
May 2014
43
95
6
Jun 2014
44
100
6
Jul 2014
49
109
6
Aug 2014
53
120
6
Sep 2014
55
134
6
Oct 2014
59
139
6
Nov 2014
63
145
7
Dec 2014
63
154
7
Jan 2015
63
159
7
Feb 2015
69
162
7
Mar 2015
81
165
7
Apr 2015
90
166
7
May 2015
93
166
7
Jun 2015
98
166
7
Jul 2015
105
168
7
Aug 2015
113
174
7
Sep 2015
113
176
7
Oct 2015
117
178
7
Nov 2015
126
182
8
Dec 2015
126
185
8
Jan 2016
136
190
9
Feb 2016
142
195
9
Mar 2016
149
197
9
Apr 2016
155
199
9
May 2016
161
202
9
Jun 2016
164
202
9
Jul 2016
168
202
10
Aug 2016
170
204
10
Sep 2016
172
206
10
Oct 2016
175
207
10
Nov 2016
177
207
10
Dec 2016
181
210
10
Jan 2017
187
211
10
Feb 2017
192
211
10
Mar 2017
205
214
11
Apr 2017
236
217
18
May 2017
269
217
26
Jun 2017
300
217
33
Jul 2017
309
219
34
Aug 2017
315
224
34
Sep 2017
324
230
34
Oct 2017
332
231
34
Nov 2017
345
232
34
Dec 2017
364
234
34
Jan 2018
381
237
34
Feb 2018
402
237
37
Mar 2018
416
240
37
Apr 2018
427
243
37
May 2018
437
247
39
Jun 2018
446
248
39
Jul 2018
461
251
40
Aug 2018
472
252
40
Sep 2018
482
253
40
Oct 2018
488
257
40
Nov 2018
497
260
41
Dec 2018
504
261
41
Jan 2019
514
267
41
Feb 2019
522
268
41
Mar 2019
529
271
41
Apr 2019
537
273
42
May 2019
545
274
42
Jun 2019
549
278
42
Jul 2019
554
282
42
Aug 2019
561
287
42
Sep 2019
565
287
42
Oct 2019
568
288
42
Nov 2019
574
290
42
Dec 2019
577
291
42
Jan 2020
584
292
42
Feb 2020
589
295
43
Mar 2020
591
295
43
Apr 2020
597
295
43
May 2020
604
295
44
Jun 2020
612
295
44
Jul 2020
622
303
52
Aug 2020
624
304
54
Sep 2020
627
306
54
Oct 2020
629
306
54
Nov 2020
634
310
55
Dec 2020
640
313
56
Jan 2021
645
316
56
Feb 2021
650
317
56
Mar 2021
658
320
56
Apr 2021
660
321
56
May 2021
667
323
56
Jun 2021
675
325
56
Jul 2021
681
326
56
Aug 2021
689
326
56
Sep 2021
697
328
56
Oct 2021
711
329
56
Nov 2021
722
331
56
Dec 2021
729
335
57
Jan 2022
738
336
57
Feb 2022
746
337
59
Mar 2022
755
338
62
Apr 2022
765
339
63
May 2022
769
339
64
Jun 2022
771
340
65
Jul 2022
773
340
65
Aug 2022
782
342
66
Sep 2022
783
343
68
Oct 2022
789
345
70
Nov 2022
797
348
72
Dec 2022
810
353
77
Jan 2023
816
354
78
Feb 2023
826
356
80
Mar 2023
838
356
80
Apr 2023
844
357
82
May 2023
849
361
82
Jun 2023
855
363
82
Jul 2023
871
364
82
Aug 2023
876
365
82
Sep 2023
884
368
83
Oct 2023
897
369
84
Nov 2023
898
369
84
Dec 2023
904
369
84
Jan 2024
910
369
84
Feb 2024
917
372
84
Mar 2024
927
375
84
Apr 2024
933
379
88
May 2024
947
383
93
Jun 2024
951
383
94
Jul 2024
963
386
96
Aug 2024
969
388
98
Sep 2024
982
389
99
Oct 2024
992
392
100
Nov 2024
1,005
392
103
Cited
Saved
Latest update: 21 Nov 2024