H. Braun
Many climate records show the occurrence of large amplitude (10–15 K), millennial-scale warming events during glacial times, the Dansgaard-Oeschger (DO) events. So far these events have almost exclusively been investigated by means of linear time series analysis. The scope of this paper is to test if the assumption of linearity is fulfilled during DO events. By means of a surrogate-based Monte Carlo method, I here demonstrate that the 60 000-year long δ18 O-record from the NGRIP ice core from Greenland allows to reject the null hypothesis of linearity beyond any reasonable level of doubt. Instead, the ice core record supports the interpretation that the events represent regime switches between different states of operation of glacial climate. As a conclusion, future studies on DO events should focus on the development and the application of more adequate (i.e., nonlinear) methods of time series analysis.
Received: 31 May 2009 – Discussion started: 01 Jul 2009
Publisher's note : Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this preprint. The responsibility to include appropriate place names lies with the authors.
H. Braun
Viewed
Total article views: 1,649 (including HTML, PDF, and XML)
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
BibTeX
EndNote
1,122
408
119
1,649
96
132
HTML: 1,122
PDF: 408
XML: 119
Total: 1,649
BibTeX: 96
EndNote: 132
Views and downloads (calculated since 01 Feb 2013)
Month
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
Feb 2013
2
5
1
8
Mar 2013
1
7
1
9
Apr 2013
1
4
0
5
May 2013
1
6
0
7
Jun 2013
1
6
0
7
Jul 2013
1
5
0
6
Aug 2013
4
0
4
Sep 2013
2
5
0
7
Oct 2013
7
0
7
Nov 2013
3
6
0
9
Dec 2013
3
10
0
13
Jan 2014
3
7
0
10
Feb 2014
4
8
2
14
Mar 2014
3
5
0
8
Apr 2014
1
4
0
5
May 2014
3
5
0
8
Jun 2014
1
5
0
6
Jul 2014
13
0
13
Aug 2014
3
8
0
11
Sep 2014
2
6
0
8
Oct 2014
5
0
5
Nov 2014
1
7
0
8
Dec 2014
6
0
6
Jan 2015
1
8
0
9
Feb 2015
6
2
0
8
Mar 2015
9
0
9
Apr 2015
10
3
0
13
May 2015
3
0
3
Jun 2015
4
0
4
Jul 2015
7
1
0
8
Aug 2015
2
4
0
6
Sep 2015
1
0
1
Oct 2015
5
2
0
7
Nov 2015
7
1
1
9
Dec 2015
3
0
3
Jan 2016
11
2
0
13
Feb 2016
5
3
1
9
Mar 2016
7
1
0
8
Apr 2016
5
3
0
8
May 2016
4
1
0
5
Jun 2016
4
1
0
5
Jul 2016
4
1
1
6
Aug 2016
4
3
0
7
Sep 2016
2
0
2
Oct 2016
4
1
5
Nov 2016
4
1
1
6
Dec 2016
5
1
0
6
Jan 2017
7
2
1
10
Feb 2017
13
1
4
18
Mar 2017
28
10
13
51
Apr 2017
30
10
11
51
May 2017
28
8
36
Jun 2017
33
1
8
42
Jul 2017
9
1
1
11
Aug 2017
4
0
4
Sep 2017
10
0
10
Oct 2017
8
0
8
Nov 2017
8
0
8
Dec 2017
9
1
0
10
Jan 2018
10
4
0
14
Feb 2018
18
1
2
21
Mar 2018
12
2
1
15
Apr 2018
15
4
1
20
May 2018
12
6
3
21
Jun 2018
13
2
1
16
Jul 2018
12
3
2
17
Aug 2018
5
3
1
9
Sep 2018
8
2
0
10
Oct 2018
14
4
0
18
Nov 2018
17
3
1
21
Dec 2018
8
3
0
11
Jan 2019
14
2
1
17
Feb 2019
13
6
1
20
Mar 2019
11
1
0
12
Apr 2019
7
4
0
11
May 2019
9
1
0
10
Jun 2019
4
6
0
10
Jul 2019
5
4
0
9
Aug 2019
10
1
0
11
Sep 2019
3
2
0
5
Oct 2019
6
1
1
8
Nov 2019
14
2
0
16
Dec 2019
8
1
0
9
Jan 2020
10
3
0
13
Feb 2020
8
2
1
11
Mar 2020
1
2
0
3
Apr 2020
8
1
0
9
May 2020
10
2
1
13
Jun 2020
13
0
13
Jul 2020
11
8
9
28
Aug 2020
6
1
2
9
Sep 2020
2
0
2
Oct 2020
8
4
1
13
Nov 2020
11
3
1
15
Dec 2020
8
2
1
11
Jan 2021
12
5
1
18
Feb 2021
12
0
12
Mar 2021
11
2
0
13
Apr 2021
4
2
0
6
May 2021
13
3
0
16
Jun 2021
10
0
10
Jul 2021
12
2
0
14
Aug 2021
12
1
0
13
Sep 2021
11
1
0
12
Oct 2021
21
2
1
24
Nov 2021
17
4
0
21
Dec 2021
9
1
0
10
Jan 2022
27
7
0
34
Feb 2022
11
3
1
15
Mar 2022
11
1
1
13
Apr 2022
9
2
0
11
May 2022
4
3
0
7
Jun 2022
2
0
2
Jul 2022
4
1
0
5
Aug 2022
7
1
0
8
Sep 2022
2
2
0
4
Oct 2022
6
3
2
11
Nov 2022
10
4
0
14
Dec 2022
11
6
1
18
Jan 2023
4
4
1
9
Feb 2023
5
5
0
10
Mar 2023
10
2
1
13
Apr 2023
6
1
7
May 2023
7
6
0
13
Jun 2023
5
5
1
11
Jul 2023
17
1
0
18
Aug 2023
4
1
0
5
Sep 2023
14
3
4
21
Oct 2023
12
5
0
17
Nov 2023
1
1
2
Dec 2023
7
0
7
Jan 2024
8
0
8
Feb 2024
8
1
0
9
Mar 2024
21
1
3
25
Apr 2024
6
1
1
8
May 2024
13
2
7
22
Jun 2024
7
0
7
Jul 2024
10
1
4
15
Aug 2024
13
0
13
Sep 2024
5
1
0
6
Oct 2024
5
1
0
6
Nov 2024
6
3
2
11
Dec 2024
1
0
1
Cumulative views and downloads
(calculated since 01 Feb 2013)
Month
HTML views
PDF downloads
XML downloads
Feb 2013
2
5
1
Mar 2013
3
12
2
Apr 2013
4
16
2
May 2013
5
22
2
Jun 2013
6
28
2
Jul 2013
7
33
2
Aug 2013
7
37
2
Sep 2013
9
42
2
Oct 2013
9
49
2
Nov 2013
12
55
2
Dec 2013
15
65
2
Jan 2014
18
72
2
Feb 2014
22
80
4
Mar 2014
25
85
4
Apr 2014
26
89
4
May 2014
29
94
4
Jun 2014
30
99
4
Jul 2014
30
112
4
Aug 2014
33
120
4
Sep 2014
35
126
4
Oct 2014
35
131
4
Nov 2014
36
138
4
Dec 2014
36
144
4
Jan 2015
37
152
4
Feb 2015
43
154
4
Mar 2015
52
154
4
Apr 2015
62
157
4
May 2015
65
157
4
Jun 2015
69
157
4
Jul 2015
76
158
4
Aug 2015
78
162
4
Sep 2015
78
163
4
Oct 2015
83
165
4
Nov 2015
90
166
5
Dec 2015
90
169
5
Jan 2016
101
171
5
Feb 2016
106
174
6
Mar 2016
113
175
6
Apr 2016
118
178
6
May 2016
122
179
6
Jun 2016
126
180
6
Jul 2016
130
181
7
Aug 2016
134
184
7
Sep 2016
136
184
7
Oct 2016
140
184
8
Nov 2016
144
185
9
Dec 2016
149
186
9
Jan 2017
156
188
10
Feb 2017
169
189
14
Mar 2017
197
199
27
Apr 2017
227
209
38
May 2017
255
209
46
Jun 2017
288
210
54
Jul 2017
297
211
55
Aug 2017
301
211
55
Sep 2017
311
211
55
Oct 2017
319
211
55
Nov 2017
327
211
55
Dec 2017
336
212
55
Jan 2018
346
216
55
Feb 2018
364
217
57
Mar 2018
376
219
58
Apr 2018
391
223
59
May 2018
403
229
62
Jun 2018
416
231
63
Jul 2018
428
234
65
Aug 2018
433
237
66
Sep 2018
441
239
66
Oct 2018
455
243
66
Nov 2018
472
246
67
Dec 2018
480
249
67
Jan 2019
494
251
68
Feb 2019
507
257
69
Mar 2019
518
258
69
Apr 2019
525
262
69
May 2019
534
263
69
Jun 2019
538
269
69
Jul 2019
543
273
69
Aug 2019
553
274
69
Sep 2019
556
276
69
Oct 2019
562
277
70
Nov 2019
576
279
70
Dec 2019
584
280
70
Jan 2020
594
283
70
Feb 2020
602
285
71
Mar 2020
603
287
71
Apr 2020
611
288
71
May 2020
621
290
72
Jun 2020
634
290
72
Jul 2020
645
298
81
Aug 2020
651
299
83
Sep 2020
653
299
83
Oct 2020
661
303
84
Nov 2020
672
306
85
Dec 2020
680
308
86
Jan 2021
692
313
87
Feb 2021
704
313
87
Mar 2021
715
315
87
Apr 2021
719
317
87
May 2021
732
320
87
Jun 2021
742
320
87
Jul 2021
754
322
87
Aug 2021
766
323
87
Sep 2021
777
324
87
Oct 2021
798
326
88
Nov 2021
815
330
88
Dec 2021
824
331
88
Jan 2022
851
338
88
Feb 2022
862
341
89
Mar 2022
873
342
90
Apr 2022
882
344
90
May 2022
886
347
90
Jun 2022
888
347
90
Jul 2022
892
348
90
Aug 2022
899
349
90
Sep 2022
901
351
90
Oct 2022
907
354
92
Nov 2022
917
358
92
Dec 2022
928
364
93
Jan 2023
932
368
94
Feb 2023
937
373
94
Mar 2023
947
375
95
Apr 2023
953
375
96
May 2023
960
381
96
Jun 2023
965
386
97
Jul 2023
982
387
97
Aug 2023
986
388
97
Sep 2023
1,000
391
101
Oct 2023
1,012
396
101
Nov 2023
1,013
396
102
Dec 2023
1,020
396
102
Jan 2024
1,028
396
102
Feb 2024
1,036
397
102
Mar 2024
1,057
398
105
Apr 2024
1,063
399
106
May 2024
1,076
401
113
Jun 2024
1,083
401
113
Jul 2024
1,093
402
117
Aug 2024
1,106
402
117
Sep 2024
1,111
403
117
Oct 2024
1,116
404
117
Nov 2024
1,122
407
119
Dec 2024
1,122
408
119
Cited
Latest update: 13 Dec 2024