S. Brewer , L. François , R. Cheddadi , J.-M. Laurent , and E. Favre
Past climates provide a testing bed for the predictive ability of general circulation models. A number of studies have been performed for periods where the climate forcings are relatively different from the present and there is a good coverage of data. For one of these periods, the mid-Holocene (6 ka before present), models and data show a good match over northern Europe, but disagree over the south, where the data show cooler summers and winters and more humid conditions. Understanding the reasons for this disagreement is important given the expected vulnerability of the region under scenarios of future change. We present here a set of different past climate scenarios and sensitivity studies with a global vegetation model in order to try and understand this disagreement. The results show that the vegetation changes can be explained by a combination of both increased precipitation, and a reduction in the length of the growing season, controlled by a reduction in winter temperatures. The matching simulated circulation patterns support the hypothesis of increased westerly flow over this region.
Received: 21 Oct 2008 – Discussion started: 13 Mar 2009
Publisher's note : Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this preprint. The responsibility to include appropriate place names lies with the authors.
S. Brewer , L. François , R. Cheddadi , J.-M. Laurent , and E. Favre
Status: closed (peer review stopped)
Status: closed (peer review stopped)
AC : Author comment | RC : Referee comment | SC : Short comment | EC : Editor comment
- Printer-friendly version
- Supplement
Status: closed (peer review stopped)
Status: closed (peer review stopped)
AC : Author comment | RC : Referee comment | SC : Short comment | EC : Editor comment
- Printer-friendly version
- Supplement
S. Brewer , L. François , R. Cheddadi , J.-M. Laurent , and E. Favre
S. Brewer , L. François , R. Cheddadi , J.-M. Laurent , and E. Favre
Viewed
Total article views: 2,441 (including HTML, PDF, and XML)
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
BibTeX
EndNote
1,031
1,256
154
2,441
95
121
HTML: 1,031
PDF: 1,256
XML: 154
Total: 2,441
BibTeX: 95
EndNote: 121
Views and downloads (calculated since 01 Feb 2013)
Month
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
Feb 2013
3
12
1
16
Mar 2013
1
11
2
14
Apr 2013
2
8
0
10
May 2013
1
9
0
10
Jun 2013
4
11
0
15
Jul 2013
1
7
0
8
Aug 2013
2
8
0
10
Sep 2013
1
7
0
8
Oct 2013
8
0
8
Nov 2013
3
8
1
12
Dec 2013
2
6
0
8
Jan 2014
2
12
0
14
Feb 2014
4
11
3
18
Mar 2014
5
11
0
16
Apr 2014
3
10
0
13
May 2014
3
14
2
19
Jun 2014
4
17
0
21
Jul 2014
1
15
0
16
Aug 2014
5
10
1
16
Sep 2014
2
14
0
16
Oct 2014
1
12
0
13
Nov 2014
1
14
1
16
Dec 2014
2
16
0
18
Jan 2015
5
11
0
16
Feb 2015
6
8
1
15
Mar 2015
9
17
0
26
Apr 2015
9
18
0
27
May 2015
4
4
1
9
Jun 2015
6
15
0
21
Jul 2015
9
5
0
14
Aug 2015
3
6
2
11
Sep 2015
9
0
9
Oct 2015
6
13
0
19
Nov 2015
7
14
2
23
Dec 2015
1
11
0
12
Jan 2016
11
12
1
24
Feb 2016
7
14
1
22
Mar 2016
6
14
0
20
Apr 2016
6
15
0
21
May 2016
6
19
0
25
Jun 2016
4
9
0
13
Jul 2016
4
11
1
16
Aug 2016
9
14
0
23
Sep 2016
4
6
1
11
Oct 2016
2
8
0
10
Nov 2016
4
14
1
19
Dec 2016
5
6
0
11
Jan 2017
5
14
1
20
Feb 2017
15
7
4
26
Mar 2017
23
29
13
65
Apr 2017
30
30
12
72
May 2017
30
13
9
52
Jun 2017
32
14
11
57
Jul 2017
7
11
2
20
Aug 2017
4
16
0
20
Sep 2017
6
24
0
30
Oct 2017
8
23
0
31
Nov 2017
10
21
0
31
Dec 2017
9
19
1
29
Jan 2018
15
16
0
31
Feb 2018
15
8
2
25
Mar 2018
14
22
1
37
Apr 2018
9
23
1
33
May 2018
11
26
2
39
Jun 2018
7
20
0
27
Jul 2018
14
20
2
36
Aug 2018
6
19
0
25
Sep 2018
9
11
0
20
Oct 2018
8
16
1
25
Nov 2018
18
22
1
41
Dec 2018
6
15
0
21
Jan 2019
7
12
1
20
Feb 2019
2
5
0
7
Mar 2019
4
10
0
14
Apr 2019
6
13
1
20
May 2019
1
6
0
7
Jun 2019
7
9
0
16
Jul 2019
6
15
0
21
Aug 2019
7
15
0
22
Sep 2019
2
14
0
16
Oct 2019
5
11
1
17
Nov 2019
5
4
0
9
Dec 2019
6
11
1
18
Jan 2020
2
2
1
5
Feb 2020
7
4
1
12
Mar 2020
2
1
0
3
Apr 2020
1
1
0
2
May 2020
4
1
2
7
Jun 2020
6
3
0
9
Jul 2020
12
7
8
27
Aug 2020
1
2
3
6
Sep 2020
1
2
0
3
Oct 2020
5
2
1
8
Nov 2020
8
4
3
15
Dec 2020
4
5
2
11
Jan 2021
6
7
0
13
Feb 2021
6
3
1
10
Mar 2021
4
5
0
9
Apr 2021
2
2
0
4
May 2021
5
1
1
7
Jun 2021
9
2
0
11
Jul 2021
7
2
0
9
Aug 2021
12
2
2
16
Sep 2021
9
0
9
Oct 2021
17
6
0
23
Nov 2021
13
7
2
22
Dec 2021
8
1
0
9
Jan 2022
13
5
0
18
Feb 2022
7
3
1
11
Mar 2022
8
1
1
10
Apr 2022
9
2
0
11
May 2022
5
1
0
6
Jun 2022
4
1
1
6
Jul 2022
3
3
0
6
Aug 2022
14
3
0
17
Sep 2022
8
3
11
Oct 2022
4
1
1
6
Nov 2022
8
4
0
12
Dec 2022
9
2
1
12
Jan 2023
4
4
1
9
Feb 2023
7
3
0
10
Mar 2023
10
2
1
13
Apr 2023
5
1
0
6
May 2023
6
4
2
12
Jun 2023
8
2
0
10
Jul 2023
12
1
0
13
Aug 2023
9
3
1
13
Sep 2023
14
2
1
17
Oct 2023
13
2
0
15
Nov 2023
6
0
6
Dec 2023
9
0
9
Jan 2024
11
1
0
12
Feb 2024
14
6
0
20
Mar 2024
14
3
1
18
Apr 2024
6
8
8
22
May 2024
15
5
4
24
Jun 2024
11
3
2
16
Jul 2024
14
4
4
22
Aug 2024
25
1
26
Sep 2024
10
7
0
17
Oct 2024
7
8
2
17
Nov 2024
3
1
2
6
Cumulative views and downloads
(calculated since 01 Feb 2013)
Month
HTML views
PDF downloads
XML downloads
Feb 2013
3
12
1
Mar 2013
4
23
3
Apr 2013
6
31
3
May 2013
7
40
3
Jun 2013
11
51
3
Jul 2013
12
58
3
Aug 2013
14
66
3
Sep 2013
15
73
3
Oct 2013
15
81
3
Nov 2013
18
89
4
Dec 2013
20
95
4
Jan 2014
22
107
4
Feb 2014
26
118
7
Mar 2014
31
129
7
Apr 2014
34
139
7
May 2014
37
153
9
Jun 2014
41
170
9
Jul 2014
42
185
9
Aug 2014
47
195
10
Sep 2014
49
209
10
Oct 2014
50
221
10
Nov 2014
51
235
11
Dec 2014
53
251
11
Jan 2015
58
262
11
Feb 2015
64
270
12
Mar 2015
73
287
12
Apr 2015
82
305
12
May 2015
86
309
13
Jun 2015
92
324
13
Jul 2015
101
329
13
Aug 2015
104
335
15
Sep 2015
104
344
15
Oct 2015
110
357
15
Nov 2015
117
371
17
Dec 2015
118
382
17
Jan 2016
129
394
18
Feb 2016
136
408
19
Mar 2016
142
422
19
Apr 2016
148
437
19
May 2016
154
456
19
Jun 2016
158
465
19
Jul 2016
162
476
20
Aug 2016
171
490
20
Sep 2016
175
496
21
Oct 2016
177
504
21
Nov 2016
181
518
22
Dec 2016
186
524
22
Jan 2017
191
538
23
Feb 2017
206
545
27
Mar 2017
229
574
40
Apr 2017
259
604
52
May 2017
289
617
61
Jun 2017
321
631
72
Jul 2017
328
642
74
Aug 2017
332
658
74
Sep 2017
338
682
74
Oct 2017
346
705
74
Nov 2017
356
726
74
Dec 2017
365
745
75
Jan 2018
380
761
75
Feb 2018
395
769
77
Mar 2018
409
791
78
Apr 2018
418
814
79
May 2018
429
840
81
Jun 2018
436
860
81
Jul 2018
450
880
83
Aug 2018
456
899
83
Sep 2018
465
910
83
Oct 2018
473
926
84
Nov 2018
491
948
85
Dec 2018
497
963
85
Jan 2019
504
975
86
Feb 2019
506
980
86
Mar 2019
510
990
86
Apr 2019
516
1,003
87
May 2019
517
1,009
87
Jun 2019
524
1,018
87
Jul 2019
530
1,033
87
Aug 2019
537
1,048
87
Sep 2019
539
1,062
87
Oct 2019
544
1,073
88
Nov 2019
549
1,077
88
Dec 2019
555
1,088
89
Jan 2020
557
1,090
90
Feb 2020
564
1,094
91
Mar 2020
566
1,095
91
Apr 2020
567
1,096
91
May 2020
571
1,097
93
Jun 2020
577
1,100
93
Jul 2020
589
1,107
101
Aug 2020
590
1,109
104
Sep 2020
591
1,111
104
Oct 2020
596
1,113
105
Nov 2020
604
1,117
108
Dec 2020
608
1,122
110
Jan 2021
614
1,129
110
Feb 2021
620
1,132
111
Mar 2021
624
1,137
111
Apr 2021
626
1,139
111
May 2021
631
1,140
112
Jun 2021
640
1,142
112
Jul 2021
647
1,144
112
Aug 2021
659
1,146
114
Sep 2021
668
1,146
114
Oct 2021
685
1,152
114
Nov 2021
698
1,159
116
Dec 2021
706
1,160
116
Jan 2022
719
1,165
116
Feb 2022
726
1,168
117
Mar 2022
734
1,169
118
Apr 2022
743
1,171
118
May 2022
748
1,172
118
Jun 2022
752
1,173
119
Jul 2022
755
1,176
119
Aug 2022
769
1,179
119
Sep 2022
777
1,179
122
Oct 2022
781
1,180
123
Nov 2022
789
1,184
123
Dec 2022
798
1,186
124
Jan 2023
802
1,190
125
Feb 2023
809
1,193
125
Mar 2023
819
1,195
126
Apr 2023
824
1,196
126
May 2023
830
1,200
128
Jun 2023
838
1,202
128
Jul 2023
850
1,203
128
Aug 2023
859
1,206
129
Sep 2023
873
1,208
130
Oct 2023
886
1,210
130
Nov 2023
892
1,210
130
Dec 2023
901
1,210
130
Jan 2024
912
1,211
130
Feb 2024
926
1,217
130
Mar 2024
940
1,220
131
Apr 2024
946
1,228
139
May 2024
961
1,233
143
Jun 2024
972
1,236
145
Jul 2024
986
1,240
149
Aug 2024
1,011
1,240
150
Sep 2024
1,021
1,247
150
Oct 2024
1,028
1,255
152
Nov 2024
1,031
1,256
154
Cited
Saved
Latest update: 21 Nov 2024