T. Ourbak , B. Malaizé , and T. Corrège
Despite being routinely measured with δ18 O in corals, records of δ13 C are seldom presented in paleoceanographic studies. Numerous factors influence the biologically-mediated fractionation of carbon isotopes during skeletogenesis, resulting in a complex behaviour of this tracer. Here we present a long coral δ13 C series, dating back to 1475, and showing the potential impact of solar activity. We note a significant decrease of δ13 C during the Spörer and Maunder minima. We argue for a change in metabolical processes, from an autotrophical pattern to a more heterotrophical mode of feeding guided by change in sun irradiation. In addition, nearby volcanic eruptions might also have an impact and cause δ13 C shifts, depending on the dust load associated with the eruption. Following previous work, we advocate the systematic presentation of δ13 C vs. δ18 O plots in coral studies to identify whether isotopic fractionation might have been affected by change in mode of feeding.
Received: 06 Sep 2007 – Discussion started: 28 Sep 2007
Publisher's note : Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this paper. While Copernicus Publications makes every effort to include appropriate place names, the final responsibility lies with the authors. Views expressed in the text are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the publisher.
T. Ourbak , B. Malaizé , and T. Corrège
Status: closed (peer review stopped)
Status: closed (peer review stopped)
AC : Author comment | RC : Referee comment | SC : Short comment | EC : Editor comment
- Printer-friendly version
- Supplement
Status: closed (peer review stopped)
Status: closed (peer review stopped)
AC : Author comment | RC : Referee comment | SC : Short comment | EC : Editor comment
- Printer-friendly version
- Supplement
T. Ourbak , B. Malaizé , and T. Corrège
T. Ourbak , B. Malaizé , and T. Corrège
Viewed
Total article views: 2,755 (including HTML, PDF, and XML)
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
BibTeX
EndNote
2,181
431
143
2,755
120
177
HTML: 2,181
PDF: 431
XML: 143
Total: 2,755
BibTeX: 120
EndNote: 177
Views and downloads (calculated since 01 Feb 2013)
Month
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
Jan 2013
3
6
2
11
Feb 2013
3
6
1
10
Mar 2013
1
6
1
8
Apr 2013
3
5
0
8
May 2013
3
5
0
8
Jun 2013
3
6
0
9
Jul 2013
4
0
4
Aug 2013
4
0
4
Sep 2013
1
4
0
5
Oct 2013
1
8
0
9
Nov 2013
5
5
0
10
Dec 2013
2
4
0
6
Jan 2014
2
4
0
6
Feb 2014
4
10
2
16
Mar 2014
3
5
0
8
Apr 2014
3
4
0
7
May 2014
4
7
2
13
Jun 2014
1
7
0
8
Jul 2014
11
0
11
Aug 2014
3
8
0
11
Sep 2014
3
13
0
16
Oct 2014
5
0
5
Nov 2014
1
11
0
12
Dec 2014
2
11
0
13
Jan 2015
3
0
3
Feb 2015
6
1
0
7
Mar 2015
9
2
0
11
Apr 2015
9
3
0
12
May 2015
4
1
0
5
Jun 2015
4
0
4
Jul 2015
8
2
0
10
Aug 2015
3
5
0
8
Sep 2015
1
3
0
4
Oct 2015
7
2
0
9
Nov 2015
7
2
1
10
Dec 2015
2
0
2
Jan 2016
9
5
0
14
Feb 2016
5
2
1
8
Mar 2016
7
3
0
10
Apr 2016
5
2
0
7
May 2016
5
5
0
10
Jun 2016
4
1
0
5
Jul 2016
6
6
1
13
Aug 2016
3
2
0
5
Sep 2016
2
1
0
3
Oct 2016
2
0
2
Nov 2016
4
1
1
6
Dec 2016
5
4
0
9
Jan 2017
6
1
1
8
Feb 2017
14
4
18
Mar 2017
24
6
14
44
Apr 2017
36
2
9
47
May 2017
27
5
32
Jun 2017
30
7
37
Jul 2017
7
2
1
10
Aug 2017
2
0
2
Sep 2017
5
0
5
Oct 2017
3
0
3
Nov 2017
3
1
4
Dec 2017
6
1
0
7
Jan 2018
7
4
0
11
Feb 2018
14
3
17
Mar 2018
5
0
5
Apr 2018
8
2
0
10
May 2018
10
4
2
16
Jun 2018
7
2
1
10
Jul 2018
15
2
1
18
Aug 2018
9
1
0
10
Sep 2018
6
4
0
10
Oct 2018
12
4
3
19
Nov 2018
10
5
1
16
Dec 2018
7
5
0
12
Jan 2019
3
1
0
4
Feb 2019
3
2
0
5
Mar 2019
7
3
0
10
Apr 2019
7
2
1
10
May 2019
12
3
0
15
Jun 2019
3
3
0
6
Jul 2019
8
2
1
11
Aug 2019
7
2
0
9
Sep 2019
10
1
2
13
Oct 2019
3
2
0
5
Nov 2019
6
1
0
7
Dec 2019
9
2
0
11
Jan 2020
4
2
1
7
Feb 2020
4
1
1
6
Mar 2020
5
1
0
6
Apr 2020
13
1
14
May 2020
18
2
2
22
Jun 2020
12
0
12
Jul 2020
10
9
10
29
Aug 2020
3
2
3
8
Sep 2020
2
1
0
3
Oct 2020
7
2
1
10
Nov 2020
14
4
1
19
Dec 2020
11
3
1
15
Jan 2021
16
4
1
21
Feb 2021
23
1
0
24
Mar 2021
16
2
0
18
Apr 2021
10
2
0
12
May 2021
18
2
0
20
Jun 2021
21
0
21
Jul 2021
22
2
0
24
Aug 2021
43
0
43
Sep 2021
23
1
0
24
Oct 2021
36
2
0
38
Nov 2021
42
7
1
50
Dec 2021
19
2
0
21
Jan 2022
28
4
0
32
Feb 2022
23
3
0
26
Mar 2022
27
3
1
31
Apr 2022
18
1
0
19
May 2022
9
3
0
12
Jun 2022
28
1
0
29
Jul 2022
20
2
0
22
Aug 2022
27
3
0
30
Sep 2022
50
2
0
52
Oct 2022
70
3
1
74
Nov 2022
68
2
0
70
Dec 2022
100
9
1
110
Jan 2023
92
1
0
93
Feb 2023
186
2
0
188
Mar 2023
99
3
2
104
Apr 2023
23
1
0
24
May 2023
17
3
1
21
Jun 2023
24
3
1
28
Jul 2023
36
2
0
38
Aug 2023
17
1
0
18
Sep 2023
20
3
1
24
Oct 2023
24
3
0
27
Nov 2023
14
1
0
15
Dec 2023
13
1
14
Jan 2024
17
1
0
18
Feb 2024
20
2
0
22
Mar 2024
24
1
1
26
Apr 2024
8
3
6
17
May 2024
24
6
30
Jun 2024
16
3
2
21
Jul 2024
20
5
25
Aug 2024
18
2
4
24
Sep 2024
9
1
4
14
Oct 2024
4
4
1
9
Nov 2024
6
2
1
9
Dec 2024
3
3
Jan 2025
9
1
0
10
Feb 2025
11
0
11
Mar 2025
8
3
1
12
Apr 2025
7
6
1
14
May 2025
6
1
2
9
Jun 2025
19
2
3
24
Jul 2025
9
2
1
12
Aug 2025
4
1
5
Cumulative views and downloads
(calculated since 01 Feb 2013)
Month
HTML views
PDF downloads
XML downloads
Jan 2013
3
6
2
Feb 2013
6
12
3
Mar 2013
7
18
4
Apr 2013
10
23
4
May 2013
13
28
4
Jun 2013
16
34
4
Jul 2013
16
38
4
Aug 2013
16
42
4
Sep 2013
17
46
4
Oct 2013
18
54
4
Nov 2013
23
59
4
Dec 2013
25
63
4
Jan 2014
27
67
4
Feb 2014
31
77
6
Mar 2014
34
82
6
Apr 2014
37
86
6
May 2014
41
93
8
Jun 2014
42
100
8
Jul 2014
42
111
8
Aug 2014
45
119
8
Sep 2014
48
132
8
Oct 2014
48
137
8
Nov 2014
49
148
8
Dec 2014
51
159
8
Jan 2015
51
162
8
Feb 2015
57
163
8
Mar 2015
66
165
8
Apr 2015
75
168
8
May 2015
79
169
8
Jun 2015
83
169
8
Jul 2015
91
171
8
Aug 2015
94
176
8
Sep 2015
95
179
8
Oct 2015
102
181
8
Nov 2015
109
183
9
Dec 2015
109
185
9
Jan 2016
118
190
9
Feb 2016
123
192
10
Mar 2016
130
195
10
Apr 2016
135
197
10
May 2016
140
202
10
Jun 2016
144
203
10
Jul 2016
150
209
11
Aug 2016
153
211
11
Sep 2016
155
212
11
Oct 2016
157
212
11
Nov 2016
161
213
12
Dec 2016
166
217
12
Jan 2017
172
218
13
Feb 2017
186
218
17
Mar 2017
210
224
31
Apr 2017
246
226
40
May 2017
273
226
45
Jun 2017
303
226
52
Jul 2017
310
228
53
Aug 2017
312
228
53
Sep 2017
317
228
53
Oct 2017
320
228
53
Nov 2017
323
228
54
Dec 2017
329
229
54
Jan 2018
336
233
54
Feb 2018
350
233
57
Mar 2018
355
233
57
Apr 2018
363
235
57
May 2018
373
239
59
Jun 2018
380
241
60
Jul 2018
395
243
61
Aug 2018
404
244
61
Sep 2018
410
248
61
Oct 2018
422
252
64
Nov 2018
432
257
65
Dec 2018
439
262
65
Jan 2019
442
263
65
Feb 2019
445
265
65
Mar 2019
452
268
65
Apr 2019
459
270
66
May 2019
471
273
66
Jun 2019
474
276
66
Jul 2019
482
278
67
Aug 2019
489
280
67
Sep 2019
499
281
69
Oct 2019
502
283
69
Nov 2019
508
284
69
Dec 2019
517
286
69
Jan 2020
521
288
70
Feb 2020
525
289
71
Mar 2020
530
290
71
Apr 2020
543
290
72
May 2020
561
292
74
Jun 2020
573
292
74
Jul 2020
583
301
84
Aug 2020
586
303
87
Sep 2020
588
304
87
Oct 2020
595
306
88
Nov 2020
609
310
89
Dec 2020
620
313
90
Jan 2021
636
317
91
Feb 2021
659
318
91
Mar 2021
675
320
91
Apr 2021
685
322
91
May 2021
703
324
91
Jun 2021
724
324
91
Jul 2021
746
326
91
Aug 2021
789
326
91
Sep 2021
812
327
91
Oct 2021
848
329
91
Nov 2021
890
336
92
Dec 2021
909
338
92
Jan 2022
937
342
92
Feb 2022
960
345
92
Mar 2022
987
348
93
Apr 2022
1,005
349
93
May 2022
1,014
352
93
Jun 2022
1,042
353
93
Jul 2022
1,062
355
93
Aug 2022
1,089
358
93
Sep 2022
1,139
360
93
Oct 2022
1,209
363
94
Nov 2022
1,277
365
94
Dec 2022
1,377
374
95
Jan 2023
1,469
375
95
Feb 2023
1,655
377
95
Mar 2023
1,754
380
97
Apr 2023
1,777
381
97
May 2023
1,794
384
98
Jun 2023
1,818
387
99
Jul 2023
1,854
389
99
Aug 2023
1,871
390
99
Sep 2023
1,891
393
100
Oct 2023
1,915
396
100
Nov 2023
1,929
397
100
Dec 2023
1,942
397
101
Jan 2024
1,959
398
101
Feb 2024
1,979
400
101
Mar 2024
2,003
401
102
Apr 2024
2,011
404
108
May 2024
2,035
404
114
Jun 2024
2,051
407
116
Jul 2024
2,071
407
121
Aug 2024
2,089
409
125
Sep 2024
2,098
410
129
Oct 2024
2,102
414
130
Nov 2024
2,108
416
131
Dec 2024
2,108
416
134
Jan 2025
2,117
417
134
Feb 2025
2,128
417
134
Mar 2025
2,136
420
135
Apr 2025
2,143
426
136
May 2025
2,149
427
138
Jun 2025
2,168
429
141
Jul 2025
2,177
431
142
Aug 2025
2,181
431
143
Saved
Latest update: 12 Aug 2025