P. Köhler
Methane synchronisation is a concept to align ice core records during rapid climate changes of the Dansgaard/Oeschger (D/O) events onto a common age scale. However, atmospheric gases are recorded in ice cores with a log-normal-shaped age distribution probability density function, whose exact shape depends mainly on the accumulation rate on the drilling site. This age distribution effectively shifts the mid-transition points of rapid changes in CH4 measured in situ in ice by about 58% of the width of the age distribution with respect to the atmospheric signal. A minimum dating uncertainty, or artefact, in the CH4 synchronisation is therefore embedded in the concept itself, which was not accounted for in previous error estimates. This synchronisation artefact between Greenland and Antarctic ice cores is for GRIP and Byrd less than 40 years, well within the dating uncertainty of CH4 , and therefore does not calls the overall concept of the bipolar seesaw into question. However, if the EPICA Dome C ice core is aligned via CH4 to NGRIP this synchronisation artefact is in the most recent unified ice core age scale (Lemieux-Dudon et al., 2010) for LGM climate conditions of the order of three centuries and might need consideration in future gas chronologies.
Received: 24 Jun 2010 – Discussion started: 11 Aug 2010
Publisher's note : Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this preprint. The responsibility to include appropriate place names lies with the authors.
P. Köhler
Viewed
Total article views: 1,856 (including HTML, PDF, and XML)
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
BibTeX
EndNote
1,242
460
154
1,856
87
134
HTML: 1,242
PDF: 460
XML: 154
Total: 1,856
BibTeX: 87
EndNote: 134
Views and downloads (calculated since 01 Feb 2013)
Month
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
Feb 2013
4
9
1
14
Mar 2013
8
0
8
Apr 2013
3
5
0
8
May 2013
2
9
0
11
Jun 2013
5
6
1
12
Jul 2013
5
8
0
13
Aug 2013
4
0
4
Sep 2013
2
7
0
9
Oct 2013
2
5
0
7
Nov 2013
2
6
1
9
Dec 2013
2
8
0
10
Jan 2014
3
10
0
13
Feb 2014
2
8
3
13
Mar 2014
6
7
0
13
Apr 2014
1
6
0
7
May 2014
2
6
2
10
Jun 2014
5
0
5
Jul 2014
2
10
1
13
Aug 2014
2
10
0
12
Sep 2014
6
11
0
17
Oct 2014
4
8
1
13
Nov 2014
3
8
0
11
Dec 2014
9
8
0
17
Jan 2015
1
4
1
6
Feb 2015
7
0
7
Mar 2015
9
0
9
Apr 2015
9
6
1
16
May 2015
4
3
0
7
Jun 2015
4
0
4
Jul 2015
7
1
1
9
Aug 2015
3
3
0
6
Sep 2015
2
0
2
Oct 2015
9
3
1
13
Nov 2015
8
1
4
13
Dec 2015
2
2
0
4
Jan 2016
9
4
1
14
Feb 2016
8
5
1
14
Mar 2016
11
0
11
Apr 2016
12
1
2
15
May 2016
9
3
0
12
Jun 2016
8
1
0
9
Jul 2016
6
2
1
9
Aug 2016
5
4
0
9
Sep 2016
6
1
7
Oct 2016
7
0
7
Nov 2016
6
3
1
10
Dec 2016
7
2
0
9
Jan 2017
7
1
1
9
Feb 2017
16
4
20
Mar 2017
26
2
13
41
Apr 2017
40
33
14
87
May 2017
33
2
10
45
Jun 2017
32
4
8
44
Jul 2017
15
2
2
19
Aug 2017
9
0
9
Sep 2017
10
1
0
11
Oct 2017
5
0
5
Nov 2017
9
0
9
Dec 2017
17
1
1
19
Jan 2018
16
3
0
19
Feb 2018
17
3
20
Mar 2018
13
2
2
17
Apr 2018
16
4
0
20
May 2018
12
8
3
23
Jun 2018
8
1
0
9
Jul 2018
15
6
3
24
Aug 2018
7
5
0
12
Sep 2018
7
4
0
11
Oct 2018
14
4
1
19
Nov 2018
11
3
1
15
Dec 2018
9
4
0
13
Jan 2019
4
2
1
7
Feb 2019
9
0
9
Mar 2019
6
3
0
9
Apr 2019
10
0
10
May 2019
7
2
0
9
Jun 2019
9
1
0
10
Jul 2019
7
1
0
8
Aug 2019
8
1
0
9
Sep 2019
6
1
0
7
Oct 2019
8
3
0
11
Nov 2019
13
1
0
14
Dec 2019
16
1
1
18
Jan 2020
11
3
1
15
Feb 2020
10
3
1
14
Mar 2020
5
3
1
9
Apr 2020
9
2
1
12
May 2020
7
1
0
8
Jun 2020
12
1
0
13
Jul 2020
12
9
9
30
Aug 2020
3
4
3
10
Sep 2020
10
1
1
12
Oct 2020
10
5
1
16
Nov 2020
8
4
1
13
Dec 2020
12
3
3
18
Jan 2021
6
4
0
10
Feb 2021
5
2
0
7
Mar 2021
13
2
3
18
Apr 2021
5
1
0
6
May 2021
9
1
0
10
Jun 2021
4
1
5
Jul 2021
4
2
1
7
Aug 2021
5
0
5
Sep 2021
4
1
0
5
Oct 2021
9
3
0
12
Nov 2021
12
7
0
19
Dec 2021
4
3
0
7
Jan 2022
9
4
0
13
Feb 2022
4
1
0
5
Mar 2022
9
1
1
11
Apr 2022
8
1
0
9
May 2022
3
1
0
4
Jun 2022
3
1
4
Jul 2022
4
0
4
Aug 2022
11
1
0
12
Sep 2022
7
3
1
11
Oct 2022
9
4
0
13
Nov 2022
9
5
0
14
Dec 2022
14
3
3
20
Jan 2023
6
1
0
7
Feb 2023
8
5
0
13
Mar 2023
10
2
12
Apr 2023
7
2
1
10
May 2023
4
4
1
9
Jun 2023
11
2
1
14
Jul 2023
19
0
19
Aug 2023
11
1
1
13
Sep 2023
14
5
1
20
Oct 2023
11
4
2
17
Nov 2023
6
1
0
7
Dec 2023
14
0
14
Jan 2024
16
0
16
Feb 2024
15
2
0
17
Mar 2024
17
1
18
Apr 2024
13
3
5
21
May 2024
18
2
7
27
Jun 2024
23
2
2
27
Jul 2024
13
4
2
19
Aug 2024
17
2
1
20
Sep 2024
7
2
0
9
Oct 2024
8
1
0
9
Nov 2024
4
1
5
Cumulative views and downloads
(calculated since 01 Feb 2013)
Month
HTML views
PDF downloads
XML downloads
Feb 2013
4
9
1
Mar 2013
4
17
1
Apr 2013
7
22
1
May 2013
9
31
1
Jun 2013
14
37
2
Jul 2013
19
45
2
Aug 2013
19
49
2
Sep 2013
21
56
2
Oct 2013
23
61
2
Nov 2013
25
67
3
Dec 2013
27
75
3
Jan 2014
30
85
3
Feb 2014
32
93
6
Mar 2014
38
100
6
Apr 2014
39
106
6
May 2014
41
112
8
Jun 2014
41
117
8
Jul 2014
43
127
9
Aug 2014
45
137
9
Sep 2014
51
148
9
Oct 2014
55
156
10
Nov 2014
58
164
10
Dec 2014
67
172
10
Jan 2015
68
176
11
Feb 2015
75
176
11
Mar 2015
84
176
11
Apr 2015
93
182
12
May 2015
97
185
12
Jun 2015
101
185
12
Jul 2015
108
186
13
Aug 2015
111
189
13
Sep 2015
111
191
13
Oct 2015
120
194
14
Nov 2015
128
195
18
Dec 2015
130
197
18
Jan 2016
139
201
19
Feb 2016
147
206
20
Mar 2016
158
206
20
Apr 2016
170
207
22
May 2016
179
210
22
Jun 2016
187
211
22
Jul 2016
193
213
23
Aug 2016
198
217
23
Sep 2016
204
217
24
Oct 2016
211
217
24
Nov 2016
217
220
25
Dec 2016
224
222
25
Jan 2017
231
223
26
Feb 2017
247
223
30
Mar 2017
273
225
43
Apr 2017
313
258
57
May 2017
346
260
67
Jun 2017
378
264
75
Jul 2017
393
266
77
Aug 2017
402
266
77
Sep 2017
412
267
77
Oct 2017
417
267
77
Nov 2017
426
267
77
Dec 2017
443
268
78
Jan 2018
459
271
78
Feb 2018
476
271
81
Mar 2018
489
273
83
Apr 2018
505
277
83
May 2018
517
285
86
Jun 2018
525
286
86
Jul 2018
540
292
89
Aug 2018
547
297
89
Sep 2018
554
301
89
Oct 2018
568
305
90
Nov 2018
579
308
91
Dec 2018
588
312
91
Jan 2019
592
314
92
Feb 2019
601
314
92
Mar 2019
607
317
92
Apr 2019
617
317
92
May 2019
624
319
92
Jun 2019
633
320
92
Jul 2019
640
321
92
Aug 2019
648
322
92
Sep 2019
654
323
92
Oct 2019
662
326
92
Nov 2019
675
327
92
Dec 2019
691
328
93
Jan 2020
702
331
94
Feb 2020
712
334
95
Mar 2020
717
337
96
Apr 2020
726
339
97
May 2020
733
340
97
Jun 2020
745
341
97
Jul 2020
757
350
106
Aug 2020
760
354
109
Sep 2020
770
355
110
Oct 2020
780
360
111
Nov 2020
788
364
112
Dec 2020
800
367
115
Jan 2021
806
371
115
Feb 2021
811
373
115
Mar 2021
824
375
118
Apr 2021
829
376
118
May 2021
838
377
118
Jun 2021
842
377
119
Jul 2021
846
379
120
Aug 2021
851
379
120
Sep 2021
855
380
120
Oct 2021
864
383
120
Nov 2021
876
390
120
Dec 2021
880
393
120
Jan 2022
889
397
120
Feb 2022
893
398
120
Mar 2022
902
399
121
Apr 2022
910
400
121
May 2022
913
401
121
Jun 2022
916
401
122
Jul 2022
920
401
122
Aug 2022
931
402
122
Sep 2022
938
405
123
Oct 2022
947
409
123
Nov 2022
956
414
123
Dec 2022
970
417
126
Jan 2023
976
418
126
Feb 2023
984
423
126
Mar 2023
994
423
128
Apr 2023
1,001
425
129
May 2023
1,005
429
130
Jun 2023
1,016
431
131
Jul 2023
1,035
431
131
Aug 2023
1,046
432
132
Sep 2023
1,060
437
133
Oct 2023
1,071
441
135
Nov 2023
1,077
442
135
Dec 2023
1,091
442
135
Jan 2024
1,107
442
135
Feb 2024
1,122
444
135
Mar 2024
1,139
444
136
Apr 2024
1,152
447
141
May 2024
1,170
449
148
Jun 2024
1,193
451
150
Jul 2024
1,206
455
152
Aug 2024
1,223
457
153
Sep 2024
1,230
459
153
Oct 2024
1,238
460
153
Nov 2024
1,242
460
154
Cited
Saved
Latest update: 21 Nov 2024