the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Monsoon-driven changes in aeolian and fluvial sediment input to the central Red Sea recorded throughout the last 200,000 years
Paul A. Wilson
Helge W. Arz
Hartmut Schulz
Gerhard Schmiedl
Abstract. Climatic and associated hydrological changes controlled the transport processes and composition of the sediments in the central Red Sea during the last ca. 200 kyr. Three different source areas for mineral dust are identified. The dominant source is located in the eastern Sahara (Sudan and southernmost Egypt). We identify its imprint on Red Sea sediments by high smectite and Ti contents, high 87Sr/86Sr and low εNd. The availability of deflatable sediments was controlled by the intensity of tropical rainfall and vegetation cover over northern Africa linked to the African monsoon. Intense dust input to the Red Sea occurred during arid phases, low input during humid phases. A second, less significant source indicated by palygorskite input is probably located on the eastern Arabian Peninsula and/or Mesopotamia, while the presence of kaolinite suggests an additional minor dust source in northern Egypt. Our grain size data reflect episodes of fluvial sediment discharge to the central Red Sea and document the variable strength in response to all of the precession-paced insolation maxima during our study interval including both those that were strong enough to trigger sapropel formation in the eastern Mediterranean Sea and those that were not. The African Humid Period most strongly expressed in our Red Sea record was the one during the Eemian last interglacial at ca. 125 ka, followed by those at 198 ka, 108 ka, 84 ka and 6 ka.
- Preprint
(6563 KB) - Metadata XML
-
Supplement
(1318 KB) - BibTeX
- EndNote
Werner Ehrmann et al.
Status: open (extended)
-
RC1: 'Comment on cp-2023-33', Anonymous Referee #1, 02 Jul 2023
reply
General comments:
This is an excellent paper that addresses the relatively under-studied eolian history of the Red Sea. The subject is of interest to the readership of the paper and will probably draw attention and referenced by future works in the region. It focuses on the central part of the Red Sea around the Tokar Gap. An interesting region that experiences large climatic variations also through winter-summer conditions, and on a larger scale of glacial-interglacial conditions it had shown large variation in the regional climatic conditions. Dust proxies usually present a messy record as there are several sources – specifically in a site that accumulated both eolian and fluvial sediments. Yet, the proxies examined here were discussed appropriately, showing an overall agreement and the text clearly demonstrates this matter. Some differences may arise regarding the interpretation, and I added the fundamental issues below, however, the paper should be published addressing few minor revisions.
Specific comments:
The authors argue that a fluvial origin of palygorskite is unlikely, however, there seem to be a correlation between rising proportions of it and EM3, and the occurrences of S events.
EM3 is considered a fluvial source and has robustly been shown to be correct in previous works in the Red Sea, even by one of the authors. How then, does this alleged discrepancy settle?
Values of 87Sr/86Sr that are higher than 0.707 accompanied with eNd values lower than -2 are not likely to reflect products of basalt weathering. Perhaps there is another source rock in the area that can provide these values? Could it be related to the palygorskite from the previous comment?
Technical comments:
Line 178: According to Fig. 3 the smectite minima at MIS5 occurred at 118-119ka and not at 125ka as stated.
Lines 396-398: The argument, to my understating, is that the alluvial fans channels and wadis stopped providing dust due to their increased hydrological activity, whereas the alluvial plains continued to do so. Thus, the process is wetting rather than desiccation, I advise to use this terminology as the revers is harder to grasp and not chronologically accurate.
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/cp-2023-33-RC1
Werner Ehrmann et al.
Werner Ehrmann et al.
Viewed
HTML | XML | Total | Supplement | BibTeX | EndNote | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
261 | 149 | 60 | 470 | 37 | 5 | 5 |
- HTML: 261
- PDF: 149
- XML: 60
- Total: 470
- Supplement: 37
- BibTeX: 5
- EndNote: 5
Viewed (geographical distribution)
Country | # | Views | % |
---|
Total: | 0 |
HTML: | 0 |
PDF: | 0 |
XML: | 0 |
- 1