Vegetation dynamics in the Northeastern Mediterranean region during the past 23 000 yr : insight from a new pollen record from the Sea of Marmara ( core MD 01-2430 )

Introduction Conclusions References


Introduction
Palynological studies carried out in the Northeastern Mediterranean region have shown that the vegetation of this region was sensitive to the climatic variations of the North Atlantic high latitudes (i.e.Heinrich events and Dangaars-Oeschger cycles) (Geraga et al., 2005;Fletcher et al., 2010a) as well as to short climatic shifts during the Holocene (Wijmstra, 1969;Roberts et al., 2001;Lawson et al., 2005;Tzedakis, 2007;Kotthoff et al., 2008aKotthoff et al., , 2011;;Pross et al., 2009).Repeated forest contractions have been associated with regional sea surface temperature cooling events probably due to the Figures enhancement of the Siberian High (SH), (Rohling et al., 2002;Marino et al., 2009;Pross et al., 2009;Kotthoff et al., 2011), which is responsible of cold and dry spells in winter (Saaroni et al., 1996).However, despite the extensive palynological investigations carried out in Northeastern Mediterranean, the nature and timing of vegetation dynamics at the onset of the Holocene is not yet fully clarified (Tzedakis, 2007).
The Holocene reforestation in the northern border of the Aegean Sea occurs earlier (at 10.2 cal) (Kotthoff et al., 2008a), than in the Black Sea, where the establishment of forests is dated to anything between 9.5 and 8 cal ka (Atanassova, 2005;Mudie et al., 2007;Shumilovskikh et al., 2012).The Sea of Marmara lies in a transitional zone between the Aegean Sea and the Black Sea and may, therefore, be a key area to clarify the timing of early Holocene reforestation in the Northeastern Mediterranean region.Moreover, no high-resolution palaeoclimatic record exists for this region displaying a direct correlation between changes in sea surface temperatures and vegetation changes at times of rapid climatic shifts during the last deglaciation (such as Heinrich event 1 (HE 1), the B ölling-Allerød interstadial (B/A), and the Younger Dryas (YD)).The first overview of the vegetation dynamics around the Sea of Marmara for the past 33 ka was based on low-resolution pollen records that suggested colder and drier pre-and post-Late Glacial Maximum (LGM) conditions, a warm and humid early Holocene, and sustained anthropogenic impact on vegetation from 3.5 14 C kyr BP onwards (Mudie et al., 2002(Mudie et al., , 2007)).Nonetheless unfavourable climatic conditions (e.g.dry/cold episodes) in the Eastern Mediterranean were also impacting prehistoric societies causing their collapse (Weiss et al., 1993;Vermoere et al., 2002).
In this paper we present a new pollen record from the topmost 7.5 m of a sediment core (MD01 2430) collected in the Sea of Marmara, covering the past 23 cal ka.The reconstructed SST from this sedimentary sequence revealed a series of cold spells during the last 15 000 yr (Vidal et al., 2010) and a surprisingly cold B/A interstadial which is in agreement with the dinocyst record (Londeix et al., 2009).Our main goals were (i) to characterize the Northeastern Mediterranean vegetation response, tempo, and amplitude to strong and weak North Atlantic abrupt climatic changes of the last Figures 23 000 yr, (ii) to verify the unexpected low temperature recorded during the B/A as suggested by dinocysts analysis and alkenone-inferred SST done on the same core (see for details, Londeix et al., 2009;Vidal et al., 2010), (iii) to identify vegetation dynamics and climatic conditions (i.e.precipitation regime) prevailing during the early Holocene, and (iv) to propose the most likely atmospheric situation that can explain the climatic record of the Marmara region.To address these questions, we focused pollen analysis to obtain a high-temporal resolution record of vegetation dynamics for the LGM, HS 1 (∼ 19-14.6 ka, Sanchez Go ñi and Harrison, 2010;Stanford et al., 2011), B/A, YD and the Holocene.
Understanding past climatic changes and their impact on vegetation is an urgent need considering that from climate change projections over the Mediterranean emerges a pronounced decrease in precipitation and increase in temperature especially during the summer season (Giorgi and Lionello, 2008).It is likely that such changes in the precipitation regime will have an impact on water resources and consequently biodiversity, increase in forest fires, and reduction in crop production (Alcamo et al., 2007).

Regional setting
The Sea of Marmara is 275 km long and 80 km wide and connects the Aegean Sea with the brackish Black Sea via the 70 m deep Dardanelles Strait to the South and the 40 m deep Bosphorus Strait to the North (Fig. 1).The present oceanography of the Sea of Marmara is characterized by the outflow of brackish water from the Black Sea, whereas saline bottom water flows in from the Mediterranean Sea, which results in a surface-water salinity of 20.1-24.6 psu ( Ünl üata et al., 1990).Major rivers flow into the Sea of Marmara only from the south.The Kocasu Rivers is the biggest modern river entering the southern shelf of the Sea of Marmar and it delivers about 90 % of the total suspended riverine sediment ( Ünl üata et al., 1990;C ¸agatay et al., 2000;Kazancı et al., 2004).The Sea of Marmara is under a dry-summer subtropical climate (K öppen, Introduction

Conclusions References
Tables Figures

Back Close
Full 1923) with a mean winter, summer, and annual temperature of 3.8 • C, 25.7 • C, and 13.7 • C respectively.Annual precipitation is ca.660 mm yr −1 (Unal et al., 2003;Kazancı et al., 2004) with most of the precipitation occurring during winter in association with the westerly depressions, while in summer the subtropical high-pressure area brings warm and dry conditions (Trewartha, 1981).In the Marmara region the potential vegetation is the eu-Mediterranean woodland near the coast of the Sea of Marmara and euxinian-type forest inland (Zohary, 1973;Roberts and Wright, 1993).

Materials and methods
The core MD01-2430 (40 • 47.81 N, 27 • 43.51 E) was retrieved during the MD123 cruise (R/V Marion Dufresne) in 2001 with a Calypso piston corer on the Western high separating the Central basin and the Tekirda basin at 580 m water depth and is 29 m long (Vidal et al., 2010).The base of the core section consists of homogeneous silty mud, gray with dark spots and thin pyrite-rich layers.A greyish-brown ash layer is present at 698-691 cm.At 350 cm a major lithologic transition corresponds to the transition from lacustrine to marine deposits.Between 320 and 230 cm a dark layer was interpreted as sapropel.A homogenous greenish silty mud characterizes the top of the sequence (Londeix et al., 2009;Vidal et al., 2010).Introduction

Conclusions References
Tables Figures

Back Close
Full

Chronology and depth-age model
The chronology is based on six accelerator mass spectrometry radiocarbon dates on mollusc samples (Table 1, Vidal et al., 2010).Although the water reservoir age is still unknown for the Sea of Marmara, we decided to use the 400-yr correction as calculated for the Eastern Mediterranean Sea and Black Sea on modern mollusc shells (Siani et al., 2000).Indeed the first marine incursion in the Sea of Marmara has been estimated at ca. 14.7 cal ka (Vidal et al., 2010) and after that reservoir age in the bottom water of the Sea of Marmara are assumed to have been similar to the estimated reservoir age of the Mediterranean.Geochemistry of the ash layer deposited at 698-691 cm in core MD01-2430 confirms that it corresponds to the marine tephra Y-2.This tephra represents the distal facies of the Cape Riva eruption of Santorini, and it had been reported in other marine sediment cores from the Sea of Marmara (C ¸agatay et al., 2000;Wulf et al., 2002).The Cape Riva eruption has been dated on deposits on land, in which four dates have a mean value and standard deviation of 18 310 ± 380 14 C yr (see for details, Pichler and Friedrich, 1976;Eriksen et al., 1990;Kwiecien et al., 2008).
In order to prepare the depth-age model, the radiocarbon dates were converted to calendar years BP with the CALIB rev 5 program (Stuiver et al., 1998).We used the Marine04 calibration curve (Hughen et al., 2004) for the dates based on molluscs and the IntCal04 dataset (Reimer et al., 2004) for the Y-2 tephra age.The depth-age model was based on non-parametric weighted regression within the framework of generalised additive models (Fig. 2).The resulting model and associated age estimates and 95 % confidence intervals are based on the combined uncertainty of the calibrated dates and the regression line (Birks and Heegaard, 2003;Heegaard et al., 2005).The mean estimated ages used in this paper are slightly different from those published in Vidal et al. (2010).However the depth-age model of Vidal et al. (2010) is within the confidence interval of our model (Fig. 2).The mean sedimentation rate during the glacial period ranges between about 70 and 30 cm kyr −1 (19 ± 4 yr cm −1 ).Then during Introduction

Conclusions References
Tables Figures

Back Close
Full the late-glacial and early Holocene, the sedimentation rate reaches the mean lowest value of ∼ 22 cm kyr −1 (46 ± 6 yr cm −1 ).Finally, above 20 cm depth the sedimentation rate increases to 31 ± 15 yr cm −1 .

Pollen analysis
Samples of 1 cm 3 were used for pollen analysis, with Lycopodium tablets added for estimation of pollen concentration (Stockmarr, 1971).The samples were prepared as follows: coarse-sieving at 150 µm, successive treatments with cold HCl at increasing strength (10 %, 25 %, and 50 %), successive treatments with cold HF (HF 25 % for 2 1/2 h, HF 70 % 1 1/2 days), and micro-sieving (10 µm mesh).Pollen grains and spores were counted at a magnification of × 400 and × 1000 and identified using keys, pollen atlases (Moore et al., 1991;Reille, 1992Reille, -1998)), and the reference collection of the UMR EPOC, University Bordeaux 1.A minimum of 20 taxa, 100 terrestrial pollen grains (excluding Pinus, aquatic plants, spores, and unknown), and a minimum of 200 objects (including Lycopodium and terrestrial pollen grains) were counted in each sample (Finsinger and Tinner, 2005).The average terrestrial pollen sum is 160 ± 60 grains excluding Pinus, or 260 grains including Pinus.Pollen grains of Pinus are generally over-represented in marine pollen records and are therefore excluded from the pollen sum (Heusser and Balsam, 1977;Turon, 1984;Rossignol-Strick and Planchais, 1989).Maher (1981) showed how pollen percentages stabilize as the pollen sum increases, using the confidence intervals of the multinomial distribution.Rull (1987) indicated that a pollen sum of 200 grains is statistically sufficient to produce reliable estimates.Indeed, after this value there are not significant variations in the widths of confidence intervals for percentage, while for pollen counts of 100 grains the variation is of ca.distachya, E. fragilis), and upland herbs.The arboreal pollen group (AP) includes mediterranean and temperate pollen types.The program TILIA was used for plotting the pollen diagrams (Grimm, 1993).The identification of Holocene forest setbacks was based on shifts in AP percentage of at least 20 % between adjacent.The sample resolution of the pollen record of 3-10 cm allowed for an average time resolution of 115 ± 100 yr (1 standard deviation-SD) during the glacial section, 420 ± 100 yr for the late glacial and 170 ± 90 yr for the Holocene.The pollen record was zoned using the visual zonation of the pollen curves on the basis of coincident changes occurring in multiple pollen taxa.

Vegetation dynamics inferred from the pollen analysis
The pollen zone MD30-1 (22.5-21 cal ka) was dominated by herbs (Cichorioideae, Aster type, and Centaurea nigra type), steppic plants (Artemisia and Chenopodiaceae), Hippopha ë and high pollen percentage of Pinus (not included in the pollen sum) (Fig. 3a).Pollen of temperate trees (mainly Quercus deciduous type and Fagus) were also present reaching two minima at 21.7 cal ka and 21.1 cal ka.These minima correspond to an increase in Artemisia and Chenopodiaceae.Occurrence of reworked pollen (mainly Carya) most probably testifies erosion of the slope around the basin of Marmara.The landscape was dominated by open land vegetation with Hippopha ë and Pinus growing on sandy soils.This type of vegetation indicates a cold and rather dry climate during a period that falls in the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM, Mix et al., 2001) as also suggested by other records from the Sea of Marmara (Mudie et al., 2007).
At the beginning of zone MD30-2 (21-19.5 cal ka), pollen percentages of temperate trees (Quercus deciduous type, Fagus and Carpinus) increased at the cost of upland herbs, Hippopha ë and Pinus (Fig. 3a).However, the pollen influx diagram indicates that Hippopha ë was still an important component of the landscape (Fig. 3b) and the Introduction

Conclusions References
Tables Figures

Back Close
Full increase of pollen percentage of temperate trees is not fully mirrored in the influx values.We can conclude that some elements of the mesic/temperate forest most probably were present in the area around the Sea of Marmara during the LGM but the landscape was still rather open.
In zone  cal ka), temperate-tree pollen percentages of temperate tree slightly decreased while Artemisia, Chenopodiaceae and Poaceae pollen values increased.This feature is mirrored in the pollen influx diagram; the landscape was then dominated by steppic plants and upland herbs.A further dominance of Artemisia, Chenopodiaceae, Cichorioideae and herbs is visible in zone MD30-4 (16.6-15 cal ka) and it is accompanied by increases of Betula, Hippopha ë and pollen of semi-desert species (Ephedra distachya type and E. fragilis type).On the other hand pollen percentages of Quercus deciduous type, Carpinus, Fagus, Ulmus, and Tilia markedly decreased (Fig. 3a).
A sudden increase of pollen percentages of Quercus deciduous type characterized the zone MD30-5 (14.7-13.2cal ka).This change is also partly reflected in the pollen influx diagram (Fig. 3b), where an increase in the influx values of Quercus deciduous type and disappearance of Hippopha ë pollen indicate the establishment of a mesic/temperate forest.This vegetation shift clearly marks a change towards warmer/more humid climate.In zone MD30-6 (13.2-11.8cal ka) increases of pollen of steppic plants (Artemisia and Chenopodiaceae) were paralled by a reduction of pollen of mesic/temperate forests.Towards the end of this zone (ca.11.8 cal ka), Quercus evergreen type and some temperate taxa (Ulmus) pollen percentages increased.The degradation of the temperate forests indicates a colder and drier climate compared to the previous pollen zone, which corresponds to the Younger Dryas (YD) as found in the stable oxygen isotopes in Greenland (Dansgaard et al., 1993;Rasmussen et al., 2006).
The onset of the Holocene was characterized by an increase of pollen percentage of elements of mesic forests: Quercus deciduous type, Fagus, Abies, Tilia, Ulmus, Carpinus, and Corylus (zone MD30-7: 12-6 cal ka) and by the continuous pollen curve Introduction

Conclusions References
Tables Figures

Back Close
Full of Sanguisorba minor since 11.5 cal ka, followed by the appearance of Pistacia pollen.This feature is mirrored by the pollen influx values; although a sharp increase of oak pollen influx is only visible at ca. 10.5 cal ka.In this pollen zone an overall increase of the total pollen influx from two to six times corresponds to the deposition of Sapropel 1 (Fig. 3b).The occurrence of Sanguisorba minor and Pistacia can be considered as a biostratigraphic marker for the onset of the Holocene in the Eastern Mediterranean region (Rossignol-Strick, 1995;Turner and S ánchez Go ñi, 1997;Kotthoff et al., 2008a).Mesic/temperate forest is the dominant vegetation during the early-middle Holocene, characterized by Quercus deciduous type, Fagus, Abies, Ulmus, Carpinus, and Corylus pollen.This type of vegetation indicates an increase of temperature and precipitation.
Decrease of forest pollen percentages higher than 20 % were detected at ca. 9.3-9.1 and a weaker forest setback occurred at 7.9 cal ka.These forest retreats correspond to an increase of steppic plants cutting off the long-term trend in increase of forest cover.
During the middle-late Holocene (zones MD30-8 and MD30-9) an overall slight reduction of the mesic forest is suggested by the pollen spectra, though this type of forest was still dominant.A marked forest setback is detected at ca. 5.5 cal ka, mainly due to a reduction of pollen percentages of Quercus deciduous type and increase in Poaceae and Chenopodiaceae.Then short-term minima of temperate and mediterranean tree pollen occur at ca 2.1 cal ka to which correspond increases of Poaceae, Caryophyllaceae, Sanguisorba minor, Asteraceae, Cichorioideae, and Artemisia.Increases in pollen percentage of herbs were coupled with the occurrence of anthropogenic-pollen indicators (Behre, 1990;Bottema and Woldring, 1990) such as Cerealia type, Juglans and Olea that occurred since 3.1, 2.4 and 2.3 cal ka respectively (Fig. 5).Probably human exploitation of the mesic/temperate forest became stronger.Similarly, in other sedimentary cores from the Sea of Marmara the disappearance of Pinus and Quercus forests and the spread of Artemisia, Cichorioideae, and Chenopodiaceae were detected after ca.4000 yr BP (ca.4.3-4.8cal ka) and attributed to the human occupation of the area around the Sea of Marmara (Mudie et al., 2002(Mudie et al., , 2007)).Introduction

Conclusions References
Tables Figures

Back Close
Full AP percentages gradually decreased starting from about 19.5 cal ka at the benefit of steppic plants (Fig. 3a).Then a minimum in AP pollen percentages was reached between ca.17-15 cal ka, pollen of steppic plants increased (up to 50 %) and pollen of semi-desert species (Ephedra sp.) were present.Similarly during this period (19.5-15 cal ka) thermophilic dinocysts almost disappeared: a first decrease is visible at ca. 18.4 cal ka and a second one at 16.4 cal ka.Cool dinocysts were instead present with stable values until 16.4 cal ka, when Spiniferites cruciformis became the dominant dynocyst (Fig. 4).Increase in steppic plants and cold dinocysts were also found in other Introduction

Conclusions References
Tables Figures

Back Close
Full cores from the Sea of Marmara (Mudie et al., 2007) and in the Aegean Sea (Geraga et al., 2010;Kotthoff et al., 2011) suggesting that at that time climatic conditions were more critical, e.g.colder and drier than the conditions during the LGM.Moreover this phase can be subdivided in a first half (up to 17 cal ka), which was probably wetter than the second half (17-15 cal ka).A similar dry/cold period with a two-phase pattern was also described for the Western Mediterranean (Naughton et al., 2007;Fletcher and Sanchez Goni, 2008;Fletcher et al., 2010a) and it was related to the HS 1, ∼ 19-14.6 ka (Fig. 5).Based on lake-levels changes of Lake Lisan (paleo-Dead Sea), the link between Eastern Mediterranean drought phases and HSs events was present during the past 55 ka (Bartov et al., 2003).The proposed mechanism to explain this teleconnection accounts for an intensification of the Siberian High (SH) which is responsible for severe cold and dry winter conditions and polar/continental air outbreaks over the Aegean Sea (Rohling et al., 2002;Marino et al., 2009;Pross et al., 2009;Kotthoff et al., 2011).On the other hand, the collapse of the North Atlantic Deep Water circulation likely caused an input of cold water in the Mediterranean and a consequent reduction in the evaporation.In turn, this would have resulted in a reduction in the strength and the frequency of storms and therefore a decrease in precipitation over the Eastern Mediterranean region (Bartov et al., 2003).
Starting from 14.7 cal ka pollen percentages of steppic plants decreased and a sudden increase of Quercus deciduous type and AP is detected in the pollen record indicating an increase in temperatures and moisture.Spiniferites cruciformis is still dominant (Londeix et al., 2009), indicating probable cold winters and hot summers.Alkenone-derived SST indicates low temperature most probably during spring which is the period when coccoliths preferentially produce this compound (Fig. 4) (Vidal et al., 2010).A possible scenario that might explain the apparent contradiction between the climate evidences during the B/A is that the cold SST in Sea of Marmara is the result of the arrival of freshwater from melting Northern European ice during deglaciation, while our pollen data records the terrestrial vegetation.Another apparent contradiction is present when comparing the pollen and ostracods-derived stable-oxygen isotopes Introduction

Conclusions References
Tables Figures

Back Close
Full record from core MD01-2430.The isotopes show a trend towards higher values since 14.5 cal ka which might be interpreted as an increase of evaporation.However, increase in moisture is evidenced by increase in mesic/temperate forest based on pollen data of core MD01-2430 and pollen records in the Aegean Sea (Kotthoff et al., 2008a(Kotthoff et al., , 2011) ) and in Turkey (Jones et al., 2007).This support the idea of Vidal et al. (2010) that attribute the increase in stable-oxygen isotopes values at the increase in precipitationwater δ 18 O (3 ‰-4 ‰) and not to a drought phase during the B/A.
In addition in our record maximum of AP is reached towards the Allerød (Fig. 5) similarly to what was already described in Western Mediterranean (Combourieu Nebout et al., 2009;Fletcher et al., 2010b) suggesting a warming trend from the B ölling towards the Allerød.Our finding then support the idea of a climatic contrast during B/A with Greenland and North Europe expiring a cooling trend towards the end of the B/A while climate stability or warming was evidenced in Southern Europe (Genty et al., 2006;Combourieu Nebout et al., 2009).
In core MD01-2430 an optimum in dinoflagellates indicating cold conditions is again recorded between 13 and 12.15 ± 0.25 cal ka where Bitectatodinium tepikiense and Spiniferites elongatus are found with their highest values (Fig. 4).These species are winter cool-water indicators (Turon, 1984;Marino et al., 2009), and similarly alkenonederived SST shows low values (ca. 10 • C, Vidal et al., 2010).This is in agreement with the results of pollen analysis that indicate a withdrawal of the mesic/temperate forest and increase of steppic plants, indicating cold and dry conditions during the YD.The YD has been already described in the Northeastern Mediterranean as an abrupt event characterized by a change towards more drought-tolerant type of vegetation (Wijmstra, 1969;Rossignol-Strick, 1995;Atanassova, 2005;Lawson et al., 2005;Mudie et al., 2007;Kotthoff et al., 2008a;Shumilovskikh et al., 2012).Pollen-based climatic reconstructions for the Aegean region have also shown a decline in annual temperature of ca.6 • C and a precipitation decrease of ca.300 mm (Dormoy et al., 2009;Kotthoff et al., 2011) during the YD.Introduction

Conclusions References
Tables Figures

Back Close
Full The onset of the Holocene in core MD01-2430 is marked by the establishment of a mesic/temperate forest with some element of the mediterranean forest which suggests the increase in temperature and water availability.The dinocysts record shows the association of cool and thermophilic species which might suggests a seasonal contrast in SST (Londeix et al., 2009) while alkenone SST show an increasing (Fig. 4) (Vidal et al., 2010).The late-glacial/Holocene transition as marked by the AP record in our record matches very well with changes in δ 13 C values of a stalagmite located in Sofular Cave (Northwestern Anatolia) (Fleitmann et al., 2009), indicating a forested phase during the early-middle Holocene (Fig. 5).During the Holocene forest setbacks at ca. 9.2 and 5.5 are directly associated with decrease in SST in the Sea of Marmara (Fig. 4) highlighting a connection between the SST, the resulting moisture availability, and changes in the forest cover.A major forest retreat at 5.6 cal ka was also found in northern borderlands of the Aegean Sea (Kotthoff et al., 2008a), similarly a decrease in SST was found in the Aegean Sea (Marino et al., 2009).At ca. 5.5 cal ka decrease in winter-spring rain as determined by clay layer frequency are found in the Black Sea (Lamy et al., 2006) and a dry event is visible in stable-oxygen isotopes record of Soreq Cave (Fig. 5) (Bar-Matthews et al., 1997;Bar-Matthews and Ayalon, 2011).This drought phase coincides also with a major archaeological transition (Bar-Matthews and Ayalon, 2011;Roberts et al., 2011).Strikingly, our record shows only a weak forest retreat during the most pronounced shift in temperature at 7.9-8 cal ka as recorded by SST.Similarly δ 13 C of Solfular Cave don't show any marked shifts in the values around 8 cal ka (Figs. 4 and 5) (Fleitmann et al., 2007).A pronounced vegetation shift is instead detected on the northern borderland of the Aegean Sea (Kotthoff et al., 2008b) and in Tenaghi Philippon pollen records (Pross et al., 2009) and it was associated with the 8.2 cal ka climate event.On the contrary a spreading of temperate forest was recently describe for the Black Sea region at ca. 8.3 cal ka and it was related to higher moisture availability (Shumilovskikh et al., 2012).Further decreases in AP percentages from average values between adjacent samples of 10 % might be identified at 10.4, 9.9, 6.1, 4.3, 2.9, 2.1, 1.2 and 0.3 cal ka Introduction

Conclusions References
Tables Figures

Back Close
Full and interpreted as forest set-backs to which correspond an increase of steppic plants (Fig. 5).The minor oscillations prior the human impact (ca.2.5 cal ka) can tentatively be correlated with increases in North-Atlantic ice-rafting -Bond's events (Fig. 5) (Bond et al., 1997(Bond et al., , 2001)).

Early Holocene moisture availability in the Sea of Marmara region
The early Holocene in our sequence is characterized by a sudden expansion of temperate trees at ca. 11.5 ± 0.3 cal ka (Fig. 3a) indicating an increased availability of moisture.A warm and wet early Holocene (9.5 14 C kyr BP; ca.11 cal ka) was also invoked by Mudie et al. (2007) on the basis of pollen profiles from the Sea of Marmara.Holocene reforestation occurs at only at 12 cal ka in Nisi Fen (northern Greece) (Lawson et al., 2005), only at 10.2 cal ka on the northern border of the Aegean Sea according to marine pollen sequences (core SL 152, Kotthoff et al., 2008a), at ca. 8.5 14 C kyr BP (9.5 cal ka) in the Southwestern Black Sea (Mudie et al., 2007), at ca. 8.5 cal ka in Southeastern Black Sea (Shumilovskikh et al., 2012), and at ca. 7.1-7.5 14 C kyr BP (8 cal ka) in the Western Black Sea (Atanassova, 2005).However in core SL 152 (Aegean region) a decrease in the steppic plants (Artemisia, Chenopodiaceae and Ephedra) and expansions of herbs (Centaureaceae and Cichorioideae) occurred at ca. 11.6 cal ka indicating an increase of the water availability prior the forest expansion (Kotthoff et al., 2008a).A similar pattern can be seen in the Tenaghi Philippon sequence, where the reforestation occurs ca.1000 yr after the decrease of the Artemisia and Chenopodiaceae (Pross et al., 2009).
The differing source areas for the pollen assemblages in the Sea of Marmara, Black Sea, and Aegean Sea might also explain the different timing of the reforestation.The Aegean sequence reflects the vegetation in the northern borderlands of the Aegean Sea (Kotthoff et al., 2008b) for the main input in the Sea of Marmara sediments (van Zeist and Bottema, 1991;Mudie et al., 2002;Leroy et al., 2009).We can conclude that the pollen record of core MD01-2430 mainly represents Northwestern Anatolia.Stable-carbon isotopes of Sofular Cave suggest a presence of forested ecosystem since 10.5 cal ka in Northwestern Anatolia indicating that during the early Holocene moisture was available and that the vegetation response to favourable climatic conditions was fast (Fig. 5) (Fleitmann et al., 2009;G ökt ürk et al., 2011).Conversely, a dry early Holocene is detected by various proxies in the drier parts of the Near East, in sites located in southernmost Europe, and in continental zones.In these areas the reforestation occurred only after 8 ka due to persistent arid conditions that kept moisture levels below the tolerance threshold for tree growth (van Zeist and Bottema, 1991;Stevens et al., 2001;Bottema and Sarpaki, 2003;Wick et al., 2003;Tzedakis, 2007).We can conclude that the northern borderland of Southern Europe can be considered a transitional zone where the moisture level determined an earlier (ca.11.5 cal ka) woodland expansion (e.g.Northern Anatolia as shown by our data) or a later expansion in ecological stressed areas (Tzedakis et al., 2004;Tzedakis, 2007).The importance of the water availability (especially during winter) for the establishment of forest was highlighted by pollen-based climatic reconstructions (Kotthoff et al., 2008b;Dormoy et al., 2009).Recently climate simulations have shown that across the early Holocene stronger winter precipitation occurred over the Northeastern Mediterranean (near Turkey) while there is little evidence for summer precipitation in the Eastern Mediterranean (Brayshaw et al., 2011).The mechanism associated with winter precipitation in Eastern Mediterranean is not yet fully understood (Giorgi and Lionello, 2008).Evidence from paleo-data suggests that negative rainfall anomalies in the Black Sea region occurred during phases of high North Atlantic Oscillations (NAO) causing intervals of lower clay-layer frequencies (Lamy et al., 2006).A role of the Siberian High (SH) which is responsible for severe cold and dry winter conditions and polar/continental air outbreaks over the Aegean Sea (Rohling et al., 2002) , 2009) and centennial-scale SST cooling events in the Aegean Sea (Marino et al., 2009).Finally comparison of palaeolimnological records from Eastern and Western Mediterranean has highlighted that NAO forcing alone cannot explain the hydrology pattern in Eastern Mediterranean since 900 AD (Roberts et al., 2012).In order to precisely establish the correlation between these two climate systems (SH/NAO) during the late-glacial and Holocene, it is necessary to make a comparison of our data with high-resolution pollen sequences from areas not affected by the SH (i.e.western part of the Mediterranean).

Evidences for human occupation during the Holocene
Holocene vegetation changes might be caused by variation in either climate or human activities or both.Human activities on the landscape can be detected by the increase of weeds and ruderal herbs (e.g.Chenopodiaceae, Sanguisorba minor type and Cichorioideae), domesticated species (e.g.Cerealia type, Olea, Vitis and Juglans) and an overall increase in non-arboreal pollen (NAP).However, all these pollen types can also be present in the natural vegetation, therefore care must be used in the interpretation of pollen diagrams of the Eastern Mediterranean (Behre, 1990;Bottema and Woldring, 1990).Several Neolithic settlements (namely Illıpınar, Mentese, Barcın H öy ük, Pendik, Fikirtepe, Yarımburkaz, and Toptepe) were established near the northern and southern shore of Sea of Marmara from ca. 8.4-7.4 cal ka (Roodenberg and Alpaslan-Roodenberg, 1999;Bottema et al., 2001;Rosenstock, 2005;Özdogan, 2012) possibly causing a change in the landscape (Fig. 1).Palaeoenvironmental investigations connected with archaeological excavations were carried out in the area around Illıpınar (Fig. 1).The pollen spectra of Yenisehir core (the only sedimentary core dated) show a drop in tree pollen during the Late Neolithic/Early Chalcolithic (ca.8-7.4 cal ka) and Late Chalcolithic/Early Bronze Age (ca.5.7-4.6 cal ka), indeed during these periods the area was densely populated (Bottema et al., 2001).Introduction

Conclusions References
Tables Figures

Back Close
Full On the basis of the pollen-anthropogenic approach (Behre, 1981) we can attest that our pollen diagram does not show clear traces of human activities during the early Holocene.A similar feature is clear in other pollen profiles located near Early Neolithic settlements, where a definite sign of human presence is not found, meaning that the human activities did not strongly impact the vegetation (van Zeist and Bottema, 1991;Willis, 1995;Bottema et al., 2001).On the other hand, in the pollen record of MD01-2430 core a deforestation phase was clearly detected at ca. 5.5 cal ka while a weaker forest setback occurred at 7.9 cal ka (Fig. 6).Considering chronological uncertainty, the forest setback at 5.5 cal ka might be related to the occupation phase around the nearby Illıpınar site during Late Chalcolithic/Early Bronze Age.Simultaneously, in the city of Kumtepe (ca.5.5 cal ka) and later on in Troy (ca.4.5 cal ka) there is clear evidence in increasing of openness (Korfmann, 2006;Riehl and Marinova, 2008).However the deforestation phase at 5.5 cal ka is also linked with a period of climatic deterioration (see previous section).
The presence in our pollen diagram of Juglans, Olea, Phillyrea, Ericaceae, Cerealia type, and Centaurea nigra type, as well as a steady increase of Artemisia, Cichorioideae, and trilete spores (possibly Pteridium) since ca.2.5 cal ka indicates a marked change in the landscape (Fig. 6).This pollen assemblage suggests an opening of the forests in correspondence to an increase of human activities (e.g.cultivation of cereals and possibly arboriculture).The ancient city of Daskyleion lied on the shore of Lake Manyas nearby the south-western shore of Sea of Marmara (Fig. 1) from the Bronze Age to the Roman Period (ca.2.6 cal ka-0.3 cal ka, Leroy et al., 2002).A pollen sequence from Lake Manyas indicates an increase of pollen percentage of Juglans, Castanea, Vitis, Olea, Fraxinus ornus, and Quercus (Leroy et al., 2002) which suggested a phase of intense human occupation characterised by arboriculture (the so-called Beys ¸ehir Occupation Phase -BOP) (van Zeist and Bottema, 1991;Leroy et al., 2002).
The BOP is reflected in several pollen diagram of Southwestern Turkey and it is dated from 3.5-1.4cal ka (Eastwood et al., 1998).Although Lake Manyas lies few kilometres away from the Sea of Marmara, in our pollen diagram a clear BOP cannot be detected.

CPD Introduction
Full

Conclusions
The marine pollen record from the Sea of Marmara, core MD01-2430, confirms the high vulnerability of the vegetation in Eastern Mediterranean (Northern Anatolia) to changes in the winter-spring precipitation regime and temperature.Steppic plants (such as Artemisia and Chenopodiaceae) dominated vegetation during periods with cold and dry climatic regime (e.g.HS1, YD), whereas Cichorioideae and Asteraceae and Hippopha ë dominated during the LGM.We have shown a wet to dry trend within the HS1 in the Sea of Marmara region and drier and colder conditions than during the LGM, just as was found in the Western Mediterranean (Naughton et al., 2007;Fletcher et al., 2010a), and confirming that western storm tracks penetrated during the LGM as far as the Eastern Mediterranean (Kuhlemann et al., 2008;Laîn é et al., 2009).Surprisingly our record does not show a time lag during the Holocene reforestation (ca.11.5 cal ka), pointing to the fact that Northern Anatolia lies on a transitional area compared to the Near East or continental areas (see Black Sea records), where drought was a limiting factor up to 9-8 cal ka.In our record, as soon as moisture was sufficient forest vegetation expanded, probably also indicating presence of refugia of deciduous oak near the Sea of Marmara as predicted by model simulations (Arpe et al., 2011).The anthropogenicpollen indicators approach shows that disentangling the climate from human signals in pollen sequences in the Eastern Mediterranean is still an open issue.Contemporaneous with a major regional human occupation, the major forest-withdrawal phase at 5.5 cal ka directly associated with SST lowering episodes can be linked to periods of low temperature and to winter precipitation according to pollen-independent palaeoclimatic proxies.Consistently with several paleoproxies in the Eastern Mediterranean the winter rainfall regime can be related to the SH or/and NAO.In the perspective of the future climate changes towards increased dry spells a better understanding of this climatic systems might be possible by the comparison of high-resolution paleoproxies from Eastern and Western Mediterranean.

CPD Introduction
Full  a Reservoir correction following Siani et al. (2000).b Mean and standard deviation calculated by Kwiecien et al. (2008) based on original dating series (Eriksen et al., 1990;Pichler and Friedrich, 1976).Introduction

Conclusions References
Tables Figures

Conclusions References
Tables Figures

Back Close
Full Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | 1 %.The pollen types are grouped as follows: steppic (Chenopodiaceae, Artemisia, Ephedra distachya, and E. fragilis), mediterranean (Quercus evergreen type, Olea, Phillyrea, Cistus, and Pistacia), temperate (all trees and shrubs excluding Pinus, Hippopha ë, Quercus evergreen type, Olea, Phillyrea, Cistus and Pistacia, Ephedra Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | Screen / Esc Printer-friendly Version Interactive Discussion Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | correlation between vegetation and sea surface changes in the Sea of Marmara region and integration with other records from the Northeastern Mediterranean regionThe beginning of the studied sequence of core MD01-2430 falls in the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM,Mix et al., 2001) and according with the dinocysts flora (i.e.presence of Spiniferites cruciformis, Pediastrum, and fresh-water ostracods) the Sea of Marmara was an isolated mildly brackish (caspibrackish).Dominance of Spiniferites cruciformis indicates a large seasonal contrast in the sea-surface temperatures (SST)(Londeix  et al., 2009)  (Fig.4).At that time the vegetation was dominated by open land and Hippopha ë (Fig.3a) and some peaks in Artemisia and Chenopodiaceae pollen percentages were detected, indicating short-term dry periods.An increase of thermophilic dinocysts including subtropical/tropical coastal species(Londeix et al., 2009)  occurred between 20.6 and 18.5 cal ka at about the time of an increase in temperate pollen types (Quercus deciduous type, Fagus and Carpinus) dated to 21-19.5 cal ka.Altogether these proxies indicate a change towards climatic conditions less severe than before (Fig.4).Our data support recent model simulations for the LGM (21 ± 2 ka) that indicate the presence of cold-tolerant species (Carpinus, Corylus, Fagus, Tilia, Fraxinus excelsior, Alnus, Quercus robur, and Ulmus) on the western shore of the Sea of Marmara(Leroy and Arpe, 2007;Arpe et al., 2011).
Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | , while the geographical position of the Sea of Marmara resulted in a pollen sequence that should reflect the vegetational changes on Thrace and Northwestern Anatolia.The fluvial component in the Sea of Marmara is represented only by rivers that flow from the Anatolia peninsula.However aerial pollen account Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | is instead invoke to explain the evidence of 8.2 event in Tenaghi Philippon record (Pross Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | Discussion Paper | et al.

Fig. 1 .Fig. 2 .Fig. 3b .Fig. 4 .
Fig. 1.Location of the sites discussed.(a) NGRIP ice core, North Atlantic (MC52 and VM29-191) and the Near East (speleothem from Soreq Cave).The dashed arrow indicates the Western riding of the Siberian High during winter/spring (Marino et al., 2009).(b) Highlight of the sites located in Eastern Mediterranean: sediment core in the Sea of Marmara (MD01-2430), marine cores in the Aegean Sea (SL152 and MNB3), marine core in the Black Sea (GeoB 7622-2), continental core in Greece (Tenaghi Philippon) and speleothem from Sofular Cave.Some archaeological sites are indicated by square.Map (c) indicates seasonal rainfall and the movement of depression within the Mediterranean (modify by, Boucher, 1974).Seasons of maximum rainfall are shown only for Turkey and Near East: W (winter), A (autumn), S (spring) and X (indistinct).Figures in the lows indicate annual mean frequency of depressions.